The Best Whipped Frosting

by Andie Mitchell on December 28, 2010

A good cake has a great frosting to match. Because truly, frosting makes the cake. Right?

I’m glad that we agree. Now, bear with me here because I’m going to talk science and logistics of perfecting that sweet silky cream.

The slight problem I find with many homemade frostings (versus freshly made bakery versions) is that they’re either too heavy or too sweet. Even the best buttercreams have a slightly overpowering presence on cupcakes and layer cakes. They’re delicious, don’t get me wrong, but the flavor is often a little heavy on the unsalted butter (you know that straight slick of cream coating your tongue?) or the powdered sugar isn’t as incorporated as it should be, making it slightly gritty. The texture isn’t silky enough, the flavor isn’t delicate enough, to properly balance a tender, soft-crumbed cake.

 

 

The best frostings must be so well balanced and blended that no one flavor note sticks out in isolation.  And there’s a word for that perfect blending of flavors:  ‘amplitude.’ It occurs when all of the various ingredients in something fuse to create a seamless and uniform crescendo of taste. (Malcolm Gladwell refers to amplitude in his essay, The Ketchup Conundrum, where he writes about how and why Heinz Ketchup secured the throne in the world of ketchup. It’s because of it’s unmatched flavor blending, FYI) The beauty of a frosting with high amplitude is that you don’t taste the components of the frosting separately; you taste them as one intense mix. It’s not a hit of butter, then a gritty tingle of sugar, followed by a vanilla aftertaste. It’s all at once a sweet puff of cream. A single but complex flavor and texture.

That’s what I’m looking for in a frosting.

And that’s what I found in this whipped wonder.

 

It’s somewhat of a silky, more substantial whipped cream. A puffy cloud of milk and sugar.

It’s luxurious and smooth, but only subtly sweet. Perfectly light and fluffy, and able to make an intense cake somehow delicate and dainty. Really, it’s just the thing to balance an ultra rich chocolate fudge cake.

And it’s not difficult to whip up either. Essentially, you make a roux of milk and flour, which is just a thick creamy paste, and then whip it with softened butter and granulated sugar until you’ve got a big bowl of fluff on your hands. The flavor is gently vanilla; the texture is feather-light.

I made this frosting  on Christmas Eve to top a sour cream fudge layer cake. I wanted something light enough to let the melting fudge layers to really take center stage. That kind of cake begs for a break from intensity and unrestrained decadence. It was a huge hit, and the most lovely icing I could have imagined slathered on my favorite cake.

I recommend using this recipe for any or all of the following three things: 1) a bold baked good that needs a light complement, 2) a soft, fluffy crumbed cake, 3) everlasting happiness.

Here is how to make it:

In a medium saucepan, whisk one cup of milk with 5 tablespoons of flour. Heat over medium until the mixture begins to sputter, whisking constantly.

Continue to stir as the mixture thickens. You will know it’s done when it reaches the consistency of thick cake batter, after about 7 minutes of heating and whisking.

Stir in 2 teaspoons vanilla extract and set aside to cool COMPLETELY.

Now, in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a whisk attachment, or using a hand held mixer, beat 2 sticks of softened butter (1 cup) with 1 1/4 cups of granulated sugar until light, fluffy, and white in color, about 3 solid minutes of beating on medium-high speed. You want the sugar to be totally incorporated into the butter.

Now, be sure that the milk/flour mixture has completely cooled, and add it to the butter/sugar mixture.

Beat all ingredients for about 1 minute on high speed, scraping down the bowl halfway, until they are smooth and well blended.

The frosting should be  as light and fluffy as whipped cream. Use it to frost a layer cake, to generously pipe atop 12 cupcakes, or as a main course. Really.

 

The Best Whipped Frosting

Yield: makes enough to frost one 9\\\" layer cake or one dozen cupcakes generously

Ingredients

  • 1 cup milk
  • 5 tablespoons flour
  • 2 teaspoons vanilla extract
  • 1 cup butter, at room temperature
  • 1 1/4 cups granulated sugar (not powdered sugar)

Instructions

  1. In a medium saucepan, whisk one cup of milk with 5 tablespoons of flour. Heat over medium until the mixture begins to sputter, whisking constantly. Continue to stir as the mixture thickens. You will know it’s done when it reaches the consistency of thick cake batter, after about 7 minutes of heating and whisking. Stir in 2 teaspoons vanilla extract and set aside to cool COMPLETELY.
  2. Now, in the bowl of a stand mixer fitted with a whisk attachment, or using a hand held mixer, beat 2 sticks of softened butter (1 cup) with 1 1/4 cups of granulated sugar until light, fluffy, and white in color, about 3 solid minutes of beating on medium-high speed. You want the sugar to be totally incorporated into the butter.
  3. Be sure that the milk/flour mixture has completely cooled, and add it to the butter/sugar mixture. Beat all ingredients for about 1 minute on high speed, scraping down the bowl halfway, until they are smooth and well blended. The frosting should be as light and fluffy as whipped cream.

Notes

http://www.canyoustayfordinner.com/2010/12/28/the-best-whipped-frosting/

 

{ 377 comments… read them below or add one }

Jessica @ How Sweet December 28, 2010 at 12:53 pm

I LOVE THIS FROSTING. I didn’t like frosting before this… I make this all the time for cupcakes. SO GOOD!

Reply

anita swartwood June 5, 2012 at 7:22 am

I am 70yrs young and the first time I had this awesome (mocked whip cream) My aunt brought to a family homecoming for my brother from the military on a rich mayo-chocolate cake in 1957…been using ever since

Reply

Dena September 4, 2012 at 3:11 pm

Thank you for sharing..it is nice to know that this recipe is an old family favorite.

Reply

sheri November 11, 2012 at 4:19 pm

Why did my frosting taste granulated? I mixed for quite a while!

Reply

Brandie November 13, 2012 at 1:25 pm

Mine did also! Disappointing.

Reply

mandy November 23, 2012 at 6:45 pm

u used too much sugar or the grains were to big

Reply

me March 15, 2013 at 9:52 am

you can add the powdered sugar while u mix flour with milk and heat it to thicken.

Reply

Diesel April 21, 2013 at 10:37 am

I just made another version of this recipe in which you cook the flour and milk WITH the granulated sugar. This ensures that the sugar will be completely dissolved. Turned out great and everyone LOVED it!

Reply

lisa December 27, 2012 at 6:21 am

on this recipe do i mix in the 1/4 cup sugar or just the one cup that it calls for

Reply

admin December 27, 2012 at 7:02 am

Hi Lisa,
Use 1 1/4 cups of sugar. Sorry for the confusion. I edited the recipe instructions!

Andie

Reply

Liz January 7, 2013 at 8:05 pm

We just made your whipped frosting and it is great however, it was not fluffy. Do you have any thoughts how to make it fluffy? It is flat right now

Reply

admin January 8, 2013 at 6:04 am

Hmmm…that is strange. Try beating the mixture for another two minutes on high speed to see if that adds some airiness and fluff to it.

Andie

Taylore February 15, 2013 at 3:05 pm

The instructions stated to use a stand mixer with a whisk fitting OR a hand mixer. I don’t have a stand mixer so I stuck my whisk fitting on my hand mixer and went to town. Not so good. I changed out the whisk for the regular beaters in hopes of salvaging what i had already started and that did the trick! I’m guessing my hand mixer was not as powerful as a stand mixer so it needed the beefier beaters. DELICIOUS.

Staci January 26, 2013 at 8:58 pm

What about using powdered sugar?

Reply

D January 12, 2013 at 5:35 pm

I love this frosting I’ve made it b4 it turned out great but just wondering if it would make a difference if I used a salted or unsalted butter. Or does it have to be a reg butter?

Reply

admin January 12, 2013 at 5:58 pm

Hey D,

I’d recommend using unsalted butter

Andie

Reply

D January 12, 2013 at 6:18 pm

Thanks!!!

Reply

Marcia January 18, 2013 at 5:56 am

Hi,I’ve been making this frosting for many many years and it won’t be fluffy if the butter and sugar is light and fluffy and the flour mixture isn’t hard enough and cooled throughly. You can also substitute cornstarch for the flour (1/2 the amount)

Reply

johannap73 June 19, 2013 at 11:03 pm

i have been using this frosting as my only frosting since i found the recipe the trick to it is to have everything as cold as you can possibly have it …and instead of using regular granulated sugar use caster sugar a little finer grind than regular you get a smoother result, i also sieve the flour and milk mix after it has cooked to eliminate any tiny flour lumps that form….use a nonstick pot as regular ones the flour tends to stick and changes your recipe…..your butter needs to come straight out of the fridge or only stand for 2-3 minutes…..you can use unsalted but i tend to use what ever is on special at the time, if it is unsalted i add a little salt for a nicer flavor…yes the salt makes a difference…..i dont add the vanilla to the hot mix i add it last better flavor as the heat changes the taste slightly…..i have even put into this recipe blueberries that i have cooked down with a little sugar and folded them through omg devine…add cocoa to it and my husband thinks it is my real chocolate mousse that i make…soooo versatile when you get it right…..people will want the icing and forget about the cake….good luck

Reply

Robin October 4, 2013 at 3:49 pm

Hi.
Awesome whipped icing. We had no butter so I used Becel margarine. Lovely result.
In the second batch I put in 3 tablespoons of coco powder in with the flour. Great tasting! However it is really light brown in color. I am attempting to freeze the cupcakes with the icing and a container of just the icing. Hoping it will work!!

Reply

Paige December 28, 2010 at 12:54 pm

YES. As soon as I started reading this post, I knew which frosting recipe I’d see at the end. Unlike you, I’ve never been a frosting person. I mean, I enjoy it on cakes and cupcakes and cookies but in much smaller ratios than others (like my mother) find suitable. But this frosting? Pile it on. It’s perfect.

Reply

jterrill December 28, 2010 at 2:32 pm

I love cake!!! However I am usually disappointed with the frosting. So when cake is offered as the dessert at a party I will usually share a slice with my husband or pass on the cake altogether. I am very excited to add this frosting recipe to my list of “must try” recipes for 2011. Thanks for sharing! Happy New Year!

Reply

Sana December 28, 2010 at 2:33 pm

I am never satisfied with frosting- it’s always what I leave behind in my plate :(

Reply

Brittany December 28, 2010 at 5:36 pm

Thanks! I was just about to email a friend asking for a good frosting recipe, but I’ll just use this!

Reply

Stephanie @cookinfanatic December 28, 2010 at 7:32 pm

Nothing beats an amazing frosting!!! Love learning new cooking info – didn’t know that about Heinz ketchup???

Reply

thecompletecookbook December 28, 2010 at 7:45 pm

I cannot wait to make another batch of cupcakes so I can try your frosting (icing) recipe. :-) Mandy

Reply

Julie @SavvyEats December 29, 2010 at 4:46 am

I was JUST looking for a frosting recipe to use today. Looks like I’ll be going with this one! :)

Reply

Lu December 29, 2010 at 6:55 am

This sounds absolutely divine. I will be making this the next time I make a chocolate cake. I’m sure that I will find the hubby on the couch licking the frosting off of it and weeping quietly at its perfection. That would be the perfect time to ask him for a new purse.

Reply

Cindy December 29, 2010 at 8:19 am

This frosting issue is why I stopped doing cakes from scratch (at least the frosting part)

It never seems just right.
THANK YOU THANK YOU THANK YOU.

I can’t wait to experiment and also my diet is getting de – sugared again so this sort of makes me sad…hehe but Birthdays are right around the corner so I will have great excuses to experiment!

xo

Reply

Heather December 29, 2010 at 10:25 am

i tried this frosting after seeing it on tasty kitchen and totally had a love affair with it…i added peanut butter and chocolate to mine and HOLY MOLY…i die…

Reply

KnMzMommy July 3, 2012 at 10:25 am

So to make it your own flavor, you jus added extra ingredients on top of the recipe above? I’m trying to make an orange or pineapple flavored frosting…

Reply

Victoria (District Chocoholic) December 29, 2010 at 12:06 pm

I think that Baked Explorations has a similar recipe – and the authors claim it is shelf stable for up to 3 days. A HUGE plus for buffet-type parties.

Reply

Can You Stay for Dinner December 29, 2010 at 12:18 pm

Ooo great to know! Thanks Victoria!

Reply

patridew December 29, 2010 at 2:45 pm

I’ve never seen an icing recipe with flour. Can’t wait to try this one.

Reply

Linda December 29, 2010 at 4:04 pm

Can I substitute Splenda for the granulated sugar??? I tried this with homemade ice cream and it didn’t work. The texture came out gritty. Should I try it?? Thanks. If all else fails, I guess I’ll have to just suffer through with the granulated sugar!! Sounds delish. Thanks.

Reply

Can You Stay for Dinner December 30, 2010 at 4:52 am

Hey Linda! I bet Splenda would work just fine! I see no reason why not- so long as you’re using the one for baking because that can be swapped out in the same measurement as table sugar.

Reply

itsacupcakeworld December 29, 2010 at 6:32 pm

I’m not a fan of most buttercreams, and I love flour frostings. thanks for posting your recipe!

Reply

Angel January 30, 2011 at 3:45 am

Looks so taste :)

Reply

sara February 10, 2011 at 12:19 pm

I heart Malcolm Gladwell, and I heart frosting. This post couldn’t be any closer to perfection :) Trying this recipe over the weekend, hurrah!

Reply

sara February 14, 2011 at 8:21 am

Help? I tried this recipe twice over the weekend, and I’ve got one stumbling block: How do you get the sugar to incorporate into the butter, without remaining gritty? Are you using superfine sugar? I tried creaming the butter and sugar of my second batch for forever (12 minutes!), and the end frosting still had the grit :( I love the rest of the way this frosting turns out, all whippy and fluffy and perfectly sweet. I just need to figure out the sugar part….

Reply

Can You Stay for Dinner February 14, 2011 at 8:30 am

Hey Sara! No, I didn’t use superfine sugar. I think that if your butter is truly at room temp, it will gently warm the sugar enough to dissolve it with a lot of creaming. There may be the slightest bit of grittiness, but it should mostly be silky smooth. Also, I think the room temperature thickened milk/flour mixture helps to dissolve the sugar.

Reply

Regina February 8, 2013 at 8:27 am

I just came across this recipe and decided to try as written. My butter had sat out for over an hour and was very soft and I used granulated sugar. I sampled the consistency after 3 minutes and again at 6 min — very gritty. I continued mixing on high (KitchenAid stand mixer) for between 15-20 minutes and it was still gritty. The taste was excellent so I planned to use it on a cake (couldn’t let it go to waste). But, I couldn’t make the cake until the next day. I put the frosting in the fridge until I was ready to use, I put back in the mixer to whip it up after being stuffed in a plastic container. I couldn’t believe it – IT WAS NOT GRITTY ANYMORE. Very smooth and yummy!!! Thanks for posting this recipe!

Reply

Nancy January 16, 2014 at 5:33 pm

I made this frosting, my butter had been sitting out probably 12 hours when I made it. I didn’t actually check if the butter/sugar mixture felt/tasted gritty, I just went on appearances & Then mixed in the cooled milk mixture. I had absolutely no gritty texture to my finished result. Oddly, I felt like the frosting wasn’t quite sweet enough which is NEVER my issue. I always leave behind frosting because it’s -gag- level of sweet. I’m definitely going to keep trying this recipe. I actually used unsweetened coconut milk instead of dairy milk as that’s what I had on hand, I don’t use dairy milk much at all. This is probably where the sweetness got lost. The coconut milk has 0g sugar <1g total carbs per cup where milk has something like 12g. Not a huge amount but I can see where it could make a difference. I will likely try again with both "original" (sweetened) coconut milk as well as cow's milk just to see the difference.

Reply

EricaVee August 8, 2011 at 10:22 am

I agree. When I make it the sugar is still in granules even when the butter/sugar mixture is white and fluffy. It isn’t until I add the flour mixture and beat it for while that the sugar dissolves.

I LOVE this recipe and it’s all I’m using from now on. The first time I made it was for a double-layer angel food Japanese-style cheesecake. The filling was cooked strawberries, so I just used the juice from those in the frosting. YUM. Made the frosting a pretty pink/lavender color, too.

Reply

Daisy February 14, 2011 at 10:01 pm

I love love love this whipped frosting. My valentine cupcakes were a hit…..thank you for sharing the recipe.

Reply

Heather March 6, 2011 at 9:05 pm

I LOOOOOOVE this frosting! My only problem with it is that it always seperates… Do you think it could be because my kitchen is hot from baking? I promise the flour mixture is completely cooled and the butter is room temp… Any thoughts???

Reply

Angi May 12, 2011 at 10:42 am

Hey, I found this too…I actually had refrigerated it overnight to use it the next day. It separated but I found if I added flour..a little a time it smoothed it right out and didn’t change the flavor or texture at all.

Reply

Colleen January 14, 2014 at 5:18 pm

I’ve made few batches to try to get this just right. I had some of the challenges other people described- my first batch came out granular. Letting the frosting sit in the fridge overnight fixed that- and i think mixing the sugar and butter for a good long time helps too. I also experienced the separation- it sorta looked very finely curdled. I tried what another person had suggested and added a flour a little bit at a time as it mixed in my Kitchenaid. I used about 1/4 c of flour for this last step. Wow, that did the trick! I ended up with a slightly thicker, much smoother, still fluffy frosting that piped easily out of a ziplock bag. It tasted great! It wouldn’t be ideal for detail piping, but I bet you could add powdered sugar to get it more stiff (more flour would probably start to make it taste weird if you used too much). Thanks for the great recipe!

Reply

Wendy March 19, 2014 at 2:50 am

Thank you so much for the suggestion!!! I have a giant double batch of this frosting in my fridge right now for a cupcake order I’m doing. When I went to re-whip it after it sat in the fridge for a few hours, it became almost curdled looking. I was very sad! I was planning on throwing it out tomorrow and trying it again (smaller batch this time), but before I do that, I’m going to try your suggestion of adding a little more flour. I really hope it works. I hate to throw out yummy frosting.

Reply

Mrose March 18, 2011 at 4:36 am

Started reading your site today and I’m impressed with your recipes! I’m from the Philippines and most of the ingredients from sites in the US are not available here. I’m surprised that for most of your recipes, the ingredients are readily available here in my side of the world! Perfect too that I found this frosting recipe as like you, I’m sick of frosting that overpowers the cake. Question though: can I color this with coloring paste (like Wilton’s Icing Color paste)?

Reply

Can You Stay for Dinner March 18, 2011 at 7:22 am

Hi there! Yes, you can absolutely color the frosting! And Wilton makes the best icing pastes. Thank you for saying hello :)

Reply

Dawn Simons December 15, 2011 at 5:14 pm

IMHO I think Americolor makes superior icing colors. They are liquid so mix more smoothly and deepen in color over time to give a very rich and vibrant color.

Reply

Barb March 22, 2011 at 10:12 am

I have made this recipe and for some reason it is not whipping. Can it be saved? If so how?

Reply

Taylor July 20, 2011 at 11:20 am

I’m having the same problem!!

Reply

Trisha August 23, 2011 at 10:09 pm

I don’t know if these commenters will check back to this post, but just as a helpful hint, when I tried it at first with my metal flat beater in my Kitchenaid mixer, it also would not get fluffy. It was only after I changed it to the whisk beater that it whipped up well, so if you have a whisk style mixer head, that would help. Hope that helps.

Reply

kimberly May 7, 2011 at 7:49 am

I do not like frosting (too sweet!) but I am about to eat the whole bag of left over frosting! Oh my goodness!!! I followed this recipe and had WAYYY more than enough for 24 cupcakes. Amazing stuff. Thanks!

Reply

Jasmine May 13, 2011 at 3:25 pm

HOLY COW. I made this frosting for my friend’s birthday cake (plain vanilla cake with strawberries and this frosting in the middle, topped with more frosting and more strawberries) and IT IS SO GOOD! We actually ate some of it on top of the extra strawberries for lunch. :-) (Also, I think I just maxed out the number of times I can say “strawberries” in one comment.)

Reply

Ruby May 14, 2011 at 5:09 pm

Hello – thank you for posting, I made this tonight and it came out perfectly, but I did sub icing sugar for regular sugar and it came out perfect still.

1. Can this be left out at room temperature?
2. Do you know if it freezes well?
3. Have you tried to incorporate chocolate, pureed raspberries, strawberries or lemon for other flavors, and if so, how did they turn out, and how much would I use?

Thanks so much!
Ruby

Reply

johannap73 June 19, 2013 at 11:09 pm

ruby i have left this out for a couple of days ( in an airconditioned room ) and i had no problems, i have added blueberries, cocoa , chocolate ganache, flavor oils, THIS RECIPE FREEZES PERFECTLY……
when i add cocoa to it i use about 2-3 tab then taste, do everything to taste……i have added a strong solution of about 3-4 tsp of coffee and about 1 tab hot water, let that cool and gradually beat that into the frosting…omg this icing is the best, i have had marriage proposals because of it

Reply

Beth Foskey June 9, 2011 at 11:02 pm

Is this cake good for decorating?

Reply

Dolores June 13, 2011 at 10:33 am

THis is my favorite frosting/filling, etc. Depending on the cake I’m using it on, I often sub mascarpone (and some times cream cheese if it’s for carrot cake) for use as “Twinkie filling”. It’s less buttery. I love that’s it more economical than other frostings as the milk/flour paste is a good “extender” (or filler)and gives it more body! Glad you published this one, Andie! Always a winner!

Reply

Dolores June 13, 2011 at 10:37 am

OH DEAR…(I need to edit my post above).

I meant, “I often sub mascarpone (and some times cream cheese…)” FOR HALF THE BUTTER. 1 stick of butter AND 4 oz (1/2 cup) mascarpone.

Reply

Beth June 16, 2011 at 8:49 am

Does this frosting need to be refrigerated if not eaten immediately? After it is on
the cupcakes?

Reply

Saskia Andriulli July 1, 2011 at 3:36 pm

Being that it’s dairy based, I would think refrigeration is a safe idea.

Reply

Kristin June 17, 2011 at 11:52 am

THANK YOU. I’ve been using my mom’s buttercream frosting for yeeeeeeeeeaaaaaaaaaaaars and it’s just like you said, it’s a bit over powering. I. Am. Pumped. :0)

Reply

Kristen June 18, 2011 at 11:27 am

I have a question. Why is that you have listed in the ingredients 1 1/4 cups of granulated sugar but in the recipe you only use 1 cup. Did I miss something? I read through this several times and I just want to make sure that I do not screw this up.

Reply

Mya June 20, 2011 at 1:02 pm

I noticed the same thing, but I’m pretty sure it’s just a typo. If you read through the rest of the post the recipe is all written out accompanied by pictures and there it says to use all the granulated sugar (1 1/4 cups).

Reply

Saskia Andriulli July 1, 2011 at 3:35 pm

Mmmmm, mmmmmm, yum! I did the cream cheese sub mentioned above and I’m so happy with it. I also love the pb and choc idea too. I made a small change, I used a healthy cup of sugar instead of the 1+1/4 cup called for. (doesn’t seem like much, I know, but I try to cut down on sugar wherever I can). I also ran my sugar through a small food processor I have before beating it with the butter and cream cheese mix. Anyhow, thanks so much, this one is going into my recipe files!

Reply

Taylor July 20, 2011 at 11:19 am

I made this to the T, but my texture looks a little grainy and the layers are separating. Help! :(

Reply

Trisha August 23, 2011 at 10:11 pm

I think you may not have mixed the butter and sugar long enough. I kept it whipping and whipping in my mixer until it was a pure white and creamy texture, before adding the flour mixture. If the butter and sugar aren’t blended well enough, you may have trouble with graininess and separation. Hope that helps.

Reply

Cindy July 28, 2011 at 5:49 am

From the comments, it is obvious that this is a wonderful frosting and one that I will try. I have two questions: Does the frosting crust so that it can be smoothed for decorating? Can it be used to pipe decorations, ie. borders, flowers, etc.?

Reply

Marsha August 12, 2011 at 1:17 pm

This is the old-fashioned frosting that I use with Red Velvet Cake.
You do need to store it in fridge. Don’t try to keep it out for a picnic or the butter may separate. I’ve found it works best if butter is slightly chilled, or not room temp if it’s warmer.
It is very, very, very good!!

Reply

Trisha August 23, 2011 at 10:05 pm

I have been looking for a new frosting recipe, as some that I know think my decorating buttercream is too sweet. I tried this recipe out tonight, and I have to tell you, I am in love with it. It is so light, so fluffy, and colors easily. It is also easy to frost with, does not pull cake with it as it spreads, and, so far, is easily usable in decorating bags, if you’re aware that at times you’ll have air pockets in it, which should be expected with the fluffy texture of the frosting.

It took almost no time at all to prepare, and now I can’t wait to try it out on desserts for my family and friends. Thank you SO much!

Reply

Rachel September 2, 2011 at 12:05 pm

I made sure everything was at room temp and the flour/milk combo was completely cooled.. and it still turned out gritty. I thought I had the perfect recipe but am now in search of anohter. I don’t like the grit.. even if its just a little bit.. reminds me of sand in my mouth. :-(

Reply

Tonya May 22, 2012 at 8:33 am

I searched the web to find out how to make this icing like the store bakerys….wilton has this same exact recipe on their web site. so I tried it and also got that grainy testure like you are eating sand….I searched alittle more and found a comment from a bakery chef and she said they used this same recipe except after you cook your roux, then mix in your sugar to that while it is hot and it will disolve, plus the roux mixture should be completely cooled to room temp., before adding to your whippedbutter/crisco mixture and add xtract after whipping together and whip again, I tryed and it does work, if your mixture is seperating its because you are not cooling down the roux mix first.

Reply

Tonya May 22, 2012 at 8:50 am

Try this if you don’t want that buttery taste: 5 Tbsp flour
1 cup of milk
1/2 C. unsalted butter (room temp)
1/2 C. crisco shortening( I use Hi-ratio shortening for Kitchen Krafts.com)
1 C. granulated sugar
1 tsp. vanilla
Follow all directions from this site except melt your sugar into the cooked hot roux mixture first and let that cool, good luck….it worked for me…

Reply

Laura September 25, 2011 at 5:21 pm

Ok, I just want to add a few comments into the mix as someone who did actually make the frosting ( seemed like lots of them were from folks super-excited to TRY making it) 1) it is delicious, if you like very rich buttercream icing. There’s so much butter in the recipe, that it was hard not to feel like I was just eating creamed butter! I even added in extra vanilla to try to cut down on the pure butter flavor. I also had to beat mine about three times as long as suggested to get the right, non-grainy texture. My final take-the texture may be light and fluffy, but this icing is incredibly rich and really heavy on the butter. It also makes a TON. I iced a batch of 12 cupcakes and had enough left over for at least 12 more. The next time I make it, I’m going to try it with half the butter

Reply

Jami J October 3, 2011 at 9:03 am

My son’s first birthday is coming up and I’ve been looking for a light and fluffy frosting… we LOVE homemade whipped cream (whipping cream and powdered sugar) I thought about just using that for his cake, but I just don’t think it will hold up… I’m going to use this!! :D I just have one question, does it matter what kind of milk you use? We drink skim, but I didn’t know if you used 2% of whole? please let me know :)

Reply

KJ October 3, 2011 at 12:30 pm

I made this last Thursday to fill/frost 2 dozen Low-Fat Pumpkin Spice cupcakes.

It was PERFECT. :) Thank you for sharing.

Reply

Heather October 30, 2011 at 11:30 pm

I want to make this for a birthday cake. Should I use salted or unsalted butter?

Reply

Fannie November 1, 2011 at 3:23 pm

I tried this recipe and loved the taste but had some issues with the flour/milk mixture and it took forever for the sugar to dissolve to a point that it was not grainy. So I searched some more and found a recipe that was almost identical with the change of melting the sugar in the flour/milk mixture then pouring the hot mixture in the bowl of your stand mixer and beating on high for about 7-10 minutes to cool it down to a point that you can add the butter in bit by bit. Hope this helps.

Reply

Cynthia November 1, 2011 at 5:33 pm

Is it okay to use non-dairy milk?

Reply

Beth November 12, 2011 at 5:08 pm

Can this frosting be made 3 days ahead of time and kept in the fridge? What about your tye dye cupcakes? Could I bake them one day and serve 3 days later? Would they still be moist if kept in an airtight container?

Reply

janelle November 13, 2011 at 10:59 pm

i just made the frosting, but there are lumps of flour & milk mixture. only really small ones but enough to taste. did anyone else have that problem…?

Reply

summerr77 May 1, 2012 at 10:46 am

I had the same problem! I’ve made this a few times and I still can’t get out the milk/flour lumps no matter how long i beat it.

Reply

SandyHogg June 6, 2014 at 3:22 pm

You absolutely must get all the lumps out while it is heating. Flour will not dissolve in room temp or cold liquid. Whisk it before and keep whisking it while it is heating, do not stop. This is the trick to any flour mix, icing or gravy.
If this is a real problem, you can try using 1/2 as much cornstarch (no flour) and do not heat it at all. Cornstarch only dissolves in cold liquid, heating it before it dissolves makes dumplings. Some people can taste the difference between the two though.

Reply

becca November 20, 2011 at 8:03 pm

I know this frosting!!! I came across it a few months ago and have only used it since. ok that’s a lie because nothing can replace cream cheese frosting, let’s be real here. This really is the Perfect Frosting.

Reply

Rosie December 6, 2011 at 11:05 am

Do you use whole milk? Or can I use a reduced milk — either 1% or 2%. Every one of your recipes look awesome! Can’t wait to try them. Thanks.

Reply

Christine December 16, 2011 at 12:56 pm

Do you think this icing would be used well for Whoopie pies???

Anyone?

Reply

CHRISTINE December 17, 2011 at 8:41 am

So YES!!!

They are GREAT with Whoopie Pies!!!!!

I added some peppermint extract and they are the most beautiful dessert EVER!!!

My search for the perfect frosting is OVER!!

Thanks!!!!!!

Reply

Sue December 27, 2011 at 12:54 pm

Can you turn this into chocolate frosting by just adding cocoa powder, or do you need to increase the sugar?

Reply

admin December 28, 2011 at 1:12 am

Hey Sue,
I think you can just add cocoa powder, but yes, I would increase the sugar by about 1/2 cup. You might need to add more liquid to thin it a bit as well. Let me know how it goes if you try it!
andie

Reply

KitchenPrincess321 March 20, 2013 at 11:44 pm

I find that using cocoa powder makes frosting really grainy, and dry-ish. Try melting chocolate instead. I generally use semisweet chocolate chips. If you add that, then you don’t need to worry about extra sugar or liquid. I haven’t tried it with this recipe yet, but it works better from the frosting I have experienced. Just a suggestion…

Reply

Ko December 31, 2011 at 12:46 pm

I made this because it reminded me if a similar recipe ( which i can not find at the moment!) involving cooking flour/milk mixture before adding the butter/sugar. I added in a melted brick of white baking chocholate at the last step. It made a velvety white chocholate frosting that I piped onto dark choch cupcakes :)

Reply

Steve December 31, 2011 at 6:07 pm

Just put this on sugar cookies. .I don’t love frosting but this was awesome. Can’t wait to try substituting cream cheese, and other variations. Thanks for sharing

Reply

Anita Henry January 9, 2012 at 1:43 pm

I have made this frosting for many years. It is a family favorite.

Reply

RB January 13, 2012 at 4:03 pm

I tried this recipe and I suppose it turned out well. Maybe I am just not a huge fan of how overwhelmingly buttery the flavor is. I think next time I would use less butter for sure.

Reply

Tilly January 15, 2012 at 7:35 pm

I am making a wedding cake and the grooms cake. Does this icing work well on wedding cakes? does it hold up well in room temperatures or does it have to be refrigerated? Can it be used to make decorations.?

Reply

admin January 16, 2012 at 5:27 am

Hi Tilly!

Thanks for writing. I would not recommend this frosting for a wedding cake- go with a more traditional buttercream as it will hold up better. This, I fear, will wilt and be much too soft, too fluffy for that kind of decorating.

Andie

Reply

teresa April 30, 2012 at 1:36 am

I use this frosting all the time. I used it on my sons wedding cake and it worked great, Instead of regular sugar I used powder sugar. It tasted the same, but held up great. But, I do use it more
with the rest of my baking because it’s not to sweet

Reply

LIsa Cohn January 16, 2012 at 9:48 am

This is the best frosting — so whip creamish, I love it! — if you want to “color it” (for birthdays etc) add to the milk mixture at the same time as the vanilla — I am going to try next time with a bit more vanilla.

Reply

LIsa Cohn January 16, 2012 at 9:52 am

P.S. I think it really is enough for 24 cupcakes!

Reply

Katie February 3, 2012 at 9:31 am

I have been searching for a frosting to use on my daughter’s birthday cake. On most cakes I prefer just slightly sweetened whipped cream, but the since the cake will need to be frosted ahead of time and travel I need to find something studier. I like this recipe, but also found it a bit gritty and even though I cut the sugar (1 cup instead of 1 1/4) it was still WAY too sweet for my tatse. Next time I will reduce it to just 1/2 cup to start. I also like the suggestion of substituting half the butter with mascarpone….my husband is going to have me committed if I make one more practice frosting!!!
Has anyone tried it with powdered sugar? That would help with the gritty sugar element.
On another note, I did a little experiment and left half the frosting sitting in a bowl on my counter and half in a tupperware container in the fridge. I am trying to see how far ahead of the party I can make it, and how well it will hold up at an outdoor party (in Florida). So far the counter top bowl looks good, no separation and its been there over 4 hours. (Windows open and almost 80 degrees today.) It is still soft but thick enough that if I turn the bowl completely upside down it stays put. The fridgerated version has gotten firm. Tomorrow I’ll take it out and let it soften, maybe re-whip it if neccesary. I want to make as much of the party food as possible the day before:)

Reply

Beth February 4, 2012 at 12:39 pm

This is the best homemade frosting ever! Even the pickiest person I know loves it!!

Reply

Regina Bean February 19, 2012 at 6:01 pm

I just made this frosting for a carrot cake. I added mascarpone to the mixture, it tastes very much like a delicious whipped cream!!!

Reply

Melissa February 29, 2012 at 3:54 am

I want to make these for cupcakes that I need for tomorrow. Is it okay if I frost them tonight and serve them tomorrow? Will the frosting hold up?

Reply

Andie February 29, 2012 at 8:35 am

Yes, should be fine to frost them tonight and then leave them. I would suggest refrigerating tonight and then letting them come to room temperature before serving- perhaps 2 hours before they’ll be eaten, take them out of the fridge. The sugar will act as a preservative.

Reply

Claudette January 5, 2013 at 9:28 pm

I was searching for a not too sweet frosting and filling and came across yours. Absolutely the best. I made it for the first time last Saturday December 29 and left it out. Today, January 5, there is still a small slice sitting on the counter. Not once did I refrigerate and it got firmer everyday. Maybe, it is the season, but it get better every day. Made another batch today for a lemon cake. I added 1 oz crisco to mixture and was able to pipe beautifully. Will definitely use for wedding cake. Thank you so much.

Reply

Janie Mendoza March 11, 2012 at 1:29 pm

I have used this frosting & yes it is great! Now I need to decorate cupcakes for Easter. Will this frosting work like to make flowers?

Reply

admin March 13, 2012 at 7:11 am

Hey Janie! Unfortunately, no, the frosting is too light and airy to use for flower piping. I’d recommend a stiff buttercream for that. Hope it turns out great :)
Andie

Reply

Shelley March 16, 2012 at 6:25 pm

THANK YOU for this recipe!!! I’m making surprise cupcakes for dessert after dinner for my boyfriend.. I found this really good double vanilla cupcake recipe that I am going to fill with frozen raspberries and chocolate ganache and I know that it will be too rich to have any other frosting!

I’ve been watching food network all day and cupcakes are calling.. it has been a long time since I’ve baked and I love to make goodies, they just never get all eaten up so I don’t do it often.. But tonight they will!! Thank you again!

Reply

Tracy @ Pale Yellow March 29, 2012 at 4:59 pm

I made this frosting yesterday! Not only is it delicious, but it is easy and my coworkers loved it! Thanks for sharing!

Reply

Natalie March 30, 2012 at 10:52 am

Mine turned out crunchy from the sugar. Can anyone tell me how to fix this? (I Am NOT a baker…LoL) My sons party is tomorrow and really want to make this good! Please help!

Reply

jenn March 31, 2012 at 2:08 pm

hands down, the best frosting ever.

Reply

Jessica April 7, 2012 at 7:33 am

My mom has a recipe very similar to this that she uses for her red velvet cake, and it is one of my favourite frostings ever!

I totally agree that buttercream can be a bit overpowering and very unappetizing when you feel like you’re eating a sweetened stick of butter. Yesterday, I made a vanilla Swiss meringue buttercream and I just cannot enjoy the cake because of the frosting. I feel like I am eating greasy butter, and it’s pretty gross. Next time I make a cake I will go to this recipe.

Also, I would imagine you could add the sugar to the warmed milk and flour mixture to fully dissolve it and prevent the final product from being slightly grainy.

Reply

Jessica April 24, 2012 at 11:31 am

Wow! I was looking for an icing recipe for cupcakes and boy did I find a great one! Love this so much, I can see what you mean about having it for the main course :) Thank you !

Reply

rebecca April 30, 2012 at 4:45 pm

Hi there,
Is the butter in this recipe salted or unsalted?
Thanks!

Reply

summerr77 May 1, 2012 at 10:50 am

I’ve made this a few times and I’ve always let the roux cool before i add it to my creamed butter/sugar in teh stand mixer. BUt somehow I always end up with a lumpy frosting ( I can see small balls/clumps of milk/flour mixture when i spread. The sugar is totally dissolved but the texture of the frosting looks grainy/rough. Help?
xoxo,s.

Reply

Mina October 17, 2012 at 5:07 pm

Same thing happened to me. It tasted great, just had lumps. I ended up having to strain my frosting. Did you find a way to fix this?

Reply

SandyHogg June 6, 2014 at 3:51 pm

because flour will only dissolve in warmed water, and it realy really wants to make dumplings when it does, you have to whisk it the entire time it is heating, and don’t leave any lumps in the pan, they won’t dissolve later. I find if I sprinkle the flour in the warming milk and whisk while I’m doing it (not stopping) I get a smooth texture. if I dump and wait I get lumps.

Reply

kp. May 3, 2012 at 11:56 pm

hello,i’m glad i came across your site!
does anyone know if i can add raspberry jam to this frosting to make it a raspberry whipped frosting?

Reply

armywife18 June 14, 2012 at 11:39 am

Would this recipe work well on piping a character cake with the small stars?

Reply

Amy March 11, 2013 at 8:27 pm

I was able to do it successfully!

Reply

Jessica June 19, 2012 at 3:26 pm

I am having a crazy time trying to find a whipped frosting recipe that is firm enough to pipe onto a cake for decorating. This one sounds promising but I only have soy milk on hand. Does anyone know if a non-dairy milk would work the same? I try to avoid animal products as much as possible. Thanks for any info!!

Reply

Miranda July 9, 2012 at 1:49 pm

I’d imagine soy milk would work fine, but I’m curious if you also sub all of the butter in place of something else as well? I’d probably try the soy milk with coconut oil as a vegan option, although I don’t think it would hold up well to piping. Do let me know what you’ve tried and what’s worked!

Reply

Lauren July 20, 2012 at 6:51 am

Soy milk works just fine! I have used vegan margarine as a butter substitute but have run into problems when coloring it as they usually use yellow dye in margarine. So, my blue turned green! I found if dyeing I just use vegetable shortening instead. Works well!

Reply

BB October 16, 2012 at 12:32 pm

Anyone have experience/suggestions for using coconut milk instead of regular milk? Or would that end in disaster?

Reply

Tricia June 24, 2012 at 10:02 pm

I make this frosting using the following:
2 tablespoons cornstarch or 4 tablespoons flour
1 cup whole milk
1 cup butter
1 cup sugar
1 teaspoon pure vanilla

Mix cornstarch (or flour) with milk. Cook until thick, whisking the entire time. Set aside to cool. Cream butter and sugar until fluffy. Add vanilla and cooked cornstarch mixture slowly. Beat until it feels like whipped cream.

Actually I use cornstarch. Those who find it grainy are not beating the butter and sugar together long enough. It takes a long time for the granulated sugar to fully dissolve into the butter. Check it – if it still feels grainy, keep beating. Once it is fluffy, then you add the cornstarch (or flour) mixture slowly and beat until it looks like whipped cream.

I have no problem piping this frosting but I wouldn’t rely on it to make flowers etc. It does need refrigeration but you can bring to room temp prior to serving. It is my favorite frosting for any rich or delicate cake. I had a cake decorating business and cannot stand typical American buttercream frosting – too sickeningly sweet and not a good mouth feel. Anyway, this frosting is a hit with those who like a less sweet but fluffy and I prefer it to cream cheese on a red velvet cake.

Reply

Barb August 26, 2012 at 3:02 pm

I agree 100% on the Red Velvet cake comment. When we first started making it in the 1970′s (it was called the Waldorf Astoria Red Cake and had an urban myth attached to it) it had this fluffy frosting on it that we all loved. Somewhere along the line someone determined it was easier to use the cream cheese frosting. I prefer this one.

Reply

SandyHogg June 6, 2014 at 3:53 pm

I find the graininess goes away if you leave it sit. And I tend to find it is grainier the colder my butter is.

Reply

Daffodil June 25, 2012 at 7:22 am

I knew I should have looked over your site a little longer. Made your Perfect White cupcakes last night and frosted with a disappointing powdered sugar frosting. I’m almost tempted to scrape off the frosting and refrost with this recipe – next time for sure!

Reply

Leslie Galvan July 4, 2012 at 9:38 pm

Made this frosting for some lavender honey cupcakes I made today and it was absolutely AMAZING! When I was walking through the ingredients and process, I thought, ” no way this could taste good” but oh my goodness! I will continue to use this recipe only!

Reply

Miranda July 9, 2012 at 1:42 pm

I just made a small test batch and the taste is wonderful and light. I do get a bit of flour taste in the back of my throat, but I don’t think it’s something that will be noticeable once put on cake.
I tried making it using heavy whipping cream instead of milk, adding the stabilizer “whip-it,” as I’m looking for something that can hold up piping work in the florida heat and humidity without being crazy sweet. Thus far, this is the closest I have found to meeting both requirements. Whether using the whip cream and stabilizer really makes a difference, or if I’m wasting energy I can’t be sure.
I’ve done some sculptured piping work on a plate and have left it on my counter for the last hour, my kitchen probably averages 75 degrees, and while I do see a bit of separation at the base of the pipework, it is still holding up better than other versions – sticking to the plate and not gooping up or sliding off. I bet simply substituting some of the butter for crisco will solve that problem.

Reply

Miranda July 9, 2012 at 1:55 pm

*Update. I just checked the pipework again, and it now seems to have set back up and is in fact more dense/firm than when I first piped it. What was once separating at the base is no longer apparent, and I can pinch the work between my fingers slightly and feel a more firm center than what was initially made. I’m thinking the stabilizer I added must have kicked into gear? Whatever it is, it’s working beautifully!

Reply

Brittany A July 16, 2012 at 7:03 pm

Hello~! I was deciding to make a cake, but first wanted to find a great frosting. I saw this site on Google because it used the ingredients I had on-hand. I wanted to know if you could substitute the butter for margarine. :)

Thank you very much,
Brittany <3

Reply

Robin July 23, 2012 at 2:25 pm

Thank you for this wonderful recipe! It’s now my icing of choice for just about anything. I paired it with the 100 calorie chocolate cupcakes. Yum!!! It piped on easily and freezes well.

Reply

Sherry August 8, 2012 at 6:35 pm

My WHOLE family LOVED this and it’s so easy and I have to admit I was surprised, never tried anything like it before. I actually use butter instead of margarine because butter stands up better than margarine (because of the water content in margarine)

Tonight I am making a wacky cake (chocolate, made from scratch cake that gets more moist each day instead of drier) and adding some cocoa and instand coffee granules for a light mocha frosting.

Reply

Dani August 9, 2012 at 8:26 pm

Where did you find a recipe for a cake that does that?? I’d love to try it!

Reply

Cassie August 13, 2012 at 7:55 am

My sister made this frosting with her cake this weekend and it was AMAZING! My brother and I were fighting over who was going to clean the bowl LOL! I have marked this recipe down because it tastes REALLY creamy and milky and just enough sweet but not overpowering, it’s really a beautiful balance. Thank you so much for this recipe! I feel good making this for my kids too. ^_^

Reply

Tiffany August 14, 2012 at 8:47 am

Hi, I love the taste of this icing but i had a slight problem…the flour/milk mixture just would not blend very well when added to the rest of the mixture. I saw that others had this same problem but I didn’t see an answer to the problem. Any suggestions? I need to perfect this ASAP!!! Thank you! :)

Reply

SandyH June 6, 2014 at 3:59 pm

Flour does not dissolve well in cold liquid, it will clump. Wait to add the flour until you have the milk warmed up, then sprinkle the flour in while whisking the entire time. Don’t leave any lumps because they won’t dissolve later. If this seems time consuming, and it is, use 1/2 the amount of cornstarch and don’t heat it at all. Cornstarch has the opposite property of flour, it only dissolves well in cold liquid. So start with cold milk and shake well in a container. Some people can taste the difference between the two. I can’t but my dad can.
Btw once it is dissolved it can be heated or cooled with no issue. This is the secret to gravy too btw. :)

Reply

Stephanie August 15, 2012 at 10:31 pm

This is the best buttercream frosting I have ever made! So light, not too sweet, and super fluffy. The perfect add on to a rich chocholate cake. Thank you for this recipe! Looking forward to sharing with friends and family.
I tried something a little different and it was great: After I whisked the milk (I did 1/2 cup half and half + 1/2 cup nonfat milk), vanilla and flour, I refrigerated it in a seperate bowl. Then I mixed the butter and sugar very well. I added the cooled milk/flour mixture right after. I mixed it on high for another 3 minutes. It was very light and fluffy and very mixed well.

Reply

Lontegold August 25, 2012 at 1:21 am

Speechless! I never bake my whole life, but I couldn’t resist the aqua blue kitchenaid mixer because it matches my nail polish (just kidding!) … anyway, I’m almost 40 years old and tonight is the first time ever making frosting (I want to make sure I don’t fail the icing before I attempt to make the cake) and voila! Now I’m in heaven!

It took me much more than 3 minutes to beat sugar and butter (maybe 6-7min? I don’t know I just kept on trying every minute (after 3 the first initial 3 min) or so, when it still feels grainy I keep on beating), I almost gave up because while my new mixer was beating the batter I started to read comments and realized that many people got problem with it. Thankfully mine turned out perfect! Is it just beginner’s luck? Not sure but I’m too happy to care!

Thank you! *bow*

PS. I accidentally reduced the sugar to one cup, maybe it’s just a typo but for me it’s sweet enough. Just perfect. For the next times I will only use one cup of sugar :)

Reply

Barb August 26, 2012 at 2:56 pm

My mother made this frosting when I was a little girl. She got the recipe from my grandmother (Dad’s mom). So they were making this in the 50′s and 60′s. Mom always used it for her annual Bunny Cake, covered with coconut. It is wonderful. But, do not overbeat – it will curdle!

Reply

Nic Kokar September 11, 2012 at 9:13 am

This is what buttercream should be. I am done with the graininess of powdered sugar.

Reply

Randi September 14, 2012 at 6:35 am

I absolutely love this frosting. I have to admit, I was not a big whipped frosting fan before I tried this, but you have converted me.

I used this recipe on funfetti cupcakes and they were a hit. I posted rave reviews on my blog http://sugareuphoria.com/2012/09/14/whipped-frosting-that-is-absolutely-euphoric/

Thank you for sharing!

Reply

Denise September 24, 2012 at 7:22 pm

This may be the only time I have commented on a recipe. Tonight I wasted a lot of butter and sugar playing with various recipes and then I tried this one. It’s perfect. Just perfect. My 15 year old was the test and it got the thumbs up for his birthday cake. I really wanted to try to avoid the frosting in a can this year ! I am so glad you posted this! Thanks so much :)

Reply

Susan September 27, 2012 at 9:46 am

This is a delicious and light recipe. Just tried it and the taste is heavenly. Thank you so much!

Reply

Emma October 10, 2012 at 8:50 pm

When i made this, i accidentally melted the butter, it didn’t matter in any other frostings i’ve made, so i used it. That ruined the entire batch and i just wasted about $5 worth of ingredients. You really should have mentioned that is vital not to melt the butter.

Reply

Valerie November 8, 2012 at 4:03 pm

It is rude to complain about wasted money and ingredients and tell somebody to change their directions because you made the mistake and didn’t follow them. Maybe next time you should read more carefully and take your time.

Reply

Angie October 20, 2012 at 1:06 am

Can I used whip cream instead of milk?

Reply

haley October 26, 2012 at 1:17 pm

No

Reply

Claudette January 5, 2013 at 9:45 pm

I used half and half and it turned out just as creamy and fluffy. I’m sure I increased my body proportion since last Saturday. Love it.

Reply

Kathleen October 26, 2012 at 9:19 pm

can i make it the night before?

Reply

admin October 27, 2012 at 6:05 am

Hi Kathleen!
I think this is best made fresh on the day you’ll eat it.

Andie

Reply

STACY October 27, 2012 at 11:03 am

Can this be made early the day to be used and stored in the fridge until ready to use?

Reply

Brian November 4, 2012 at 5:15 pm

Thx so much, really looking forward to making this. What about a chocolate version? Just add some cocoa powder? What adjustments would I have to make? Also what about fruit flavored versions like lemon, coconut, orange, etc? Thx again.

Reply

di_braun November 11, 2012 at 9:10 am

Thanks for this frosting, used to make a coffee crisp cake, just crumbled some bars into it! Tasted great and is really nice to spread onto cake!

Reply

sheri November 11, 2012 at 4:22 pm

I like the fluffiness but can taste the grittiness. I just finished whipping it so maybe once it use it and the cupcakes sit, the grittiness will disovle?

Reply

Miranda November 12, 2012 at 8:37 am

I have to whip mine on high with my stand mixer for about 15 minutes before the grittiness begins to dissolve.

Reply

Kathleen November 13, 2012 at 1:33 pm

perfect frosting! not just a few people asked “how-did-you-make-this?”, but lots . . . a hit . . . thank you!

Reply

Jen November 14, 2012 at 1:21 pm

Will it hold up for a few days? Or will it get runny “deflate” etc…

Making birthday cupcakes and need to do it before hand. Also if we don’t eat them all that day. Will it still be yummy the next day?

Reply

Sheri November 14, 2012 at 1:46 pm

Jen, Yes the frosting will hold up, but do refrigerate them. They will still be yummy the next day.

Reply

Ashley November 15, 2012 at 7:37 am

How should I store the frosting? i.e. if I made it today and want to frost a cake with it tomorrow….

Reply

JM November 16, 2012 at 7:41 am

If one does not like the taste of butter, one can use Crisco. We used Crisco when I was growing up. It is also whiter in color with Crisco.
I like the idea of using corn starch because it can be gulten free…

Reply

Melissa November 17, 2012 at 5:56 pm

I’m going to use this to fill whoopie pies and surprise my Yankee husband on his birthday

Reply

ayla November 18, 2012 at 2:12 pm

Can i and fresh rasberrys to this if i blended them???? To make a rasberry flavored frosting

Reply

Miranda November 18, 2012 at 5:48 pm

You’re likely to wind up with a soup. If you do attempt it you’re going to have to compensate the liquid to solid ratio by adding more sugar or flour or whatever. Personally I’d recommend instead using a flavoring or extract of raspberry in place of vanilla extract.

Reply

theGoodiePlate November 19, 2012 at 4:08 pm

I love this frosting! It’s so light and the perfect amount of sweet. I’m making it my go to frosting. Thank you for sharing!

Reply

Running Betty November 22, 2012 at 11:43 am

I just made this with 1.5 tsp peppermint extract and green food coloring instead of vanilla extract and it is yumm-o!

I put it on brownies, and in an ideal world it will harden and set in the fridge over the next 2 hours so I can then put a layer of chocolate on top. We’ll see!

Reply

Brennan Abogado December 6, 2012 at 8:28 am

HEEEELLOOOOOO!!!!!! DO NOT USE GRANULATED SUGAR!!!! USE POWDERED SUGAR!!!!!!! I JUST MADE IT 2 TIMES BECAUSE WHOEVER WROTE THIS RECIPE MADE A MISTAKE BY SAYING GRANULATED SUGAR!!!!! MAKE IT WITH POWDERED AND YOU WILL SEE – IT REALLY IS AMAZING!!!!!

Reply

Lisa April 2, 2013 at 11:10 am

It was not a mistake…it is supposed to be made with granulated sugar not powdered sugar. I’ve had this frosting my whole life and it is delicious. Read the recipe before beginning so you understand the proper way to make it and you will love it!

Reply

serina December 8, 2012 at 7:03 pm

This looks delicious! but… what if i want to make a cream cheese frosting instead?

Reply

GreenT December 9, 2012 at 11:35 am

thank you for this wonderful recipe.
for christmas, i’d like to frost a chocolate cake with this.
But i’m wondering..
What is the texture like? it looks really fluffy, but i want to make the cake in advance (like, 2 days. is it going to stay stiff?
how long will this frosting last with the cake in the fridge?
It’s winter here in germany, so room temperature will be normal.
I’ll be very thankful for any help! :)

Reply

Yoli December 9, 2012 at 6:38 pm

I used heavy cream instead of milk. I sifted the 5tbs. of flour before adding it to the heavy cream.
I used powdered sugar instead of granulated sugar and then added 4tbs of raspberry jam to the overall frosting. It’s AWESOME! best frosting I’ve ever made.

Reply

Isabel December 10, 2012 at 11:48 pm

Thank you SO much for sharing this recipe! Am really glad I came across this online the other day, as I looked for a new frosting recipe to try. Made it with gluten free flour for my Godson’s Gluten free cupcakes! Turned out beautifully!! Really love how it turned out, rating on top of my favorite frostings

Reply

Tracy Lloyd December 12, 2012 at 9:37 pm

I just made this icing but mine was completely runny. I used and hand held electric whisk, although it tastes delicious I need help with how to make it look whipped it currently looks like cake batter. HELP!!!!!

Reply

Roberta January 6, 2013 at 7:00 am

Does this frosting need to be refrigerated? I am looking for a not to sweet frosting to use to make cake pops. Normally I use cream cheese frosting but would like one that doesn’t require refrigeration of the items after used.
Thanks

Reply

Claudette January 6, 2013 at 11:41 am

I live in Massachusetts and have left the finished product out of refrigeration for one whole week and believe me, it just got firmer. I even piped with it. Just try it. I am surely camping here. Don’t know what I will do with my stash of icing sugar (just kidding).

Reply

Kimberly January 8, 2013 at 4:25 pm

I have never been so in love with a frosting in my life!!! I was not intimidated by this recipe at all!! It came out beautifully, and the taste? BEST FROSTING I HAVE EVER HAD THE PRIVILEGE TO TASTE!

Reply

Jessica January 11, 2013 at 6:14 am

I used confectioners sugar instead and it was great!

Reply

esther January 12, 2013 at 4:17 am

is it possible to make this without a mixer? can i just mix/whip it manually?

Reply

admin January 12, 2013 at 5:53 am

Hey Esther,

Unfortunately, no, it’s not a good idea to try this without using a mixer of some sort. You don’t need a stand mixer, but you’ll need some electric hand beaters for the proper blending/whipping. Sorry for the bad news :/
Andie

Reply

Marlene January 16, 2013 at 11:49 am

I have tried recipes like this before and love the frosting. However, I sometimes end up with small lumps in the roux even though I constantly stir the mixture. What could I be doing wrong? Thank you for your help.

Reply

SandyH June 6, 2014 at 4:04 pm

Could you be adding the flour while the liquid is still cool? I don’t add the flour until the liquid is warm, of course whisking the entire time.

Reply

Melissa Cyrenne January 18, 2013 at 2:35 pm

So.. I found you on pinterest and made this a few times and iced an ice cream cake with it. Its perfect — not too sweet.

Then came my son’s birthday party a few weeks ago.

I just wanted to let you know that I am upset because I bookmarked this recipe on my computer and your blog was down that day and so I had to search up another whipped frosting recipe and it SUCKED.

lol — where were you when I needed you??!!

Anyway… one thing I like to do with this recipe is add a few drops of Lorrans Flavored Oils… Raspberry… watermelon.. whatever you like really. It makes it flavored.

Reply

admin January 18, 2013 at 2:40 pm

Aaahh, sorry to have failed you on the day you needed the recipe! And sad to hear the other recipe turned out poorly. I do like the idea of the flavored oils though. I’ll have to give those a try next time!

Andie

Reply

judi January 20, 2013 at 9:57 am

Does this frosting need to be refrigerated? I’m making it for my nieces birthday this week and was planning to leave it out so the icing doesn’t firm up. Is that ok? And do leftovers need to be stored in the fridge? I’m concerned about the milk.

Reply

admin January 20, 2013 at 10:35 am

Hi Judi,
This frosting will be fine if left out at room temperature for a few hours (I’d say up to 4), but yes, it should be refrigerated if you’re making it ahead of time or if you have any leftovers.

Reply

judi January 21, 2013 at 12:50 am

Thanks so much! And your recipe is amazing!!

Reply

Teresa Vaughan January 23, 2013 at 1:50 am

I use this frosting all the time. It’s my fav

Reply

Dayle January 26, 2013 at 8:26 pm

I have had this recipe for years and my favorite cake with this frosting is angel food. (from scratch) In fact, this has been my birthday cake choice for 45 years! : )

Reply

Logsy January 31, 2013 at 12:59 pm

oh yeah, oh yeah, oh yeah! Your frosting looked the best and tastes fluffy and divine. it’s just as ‘Goldilocks” would of liked it. Thank you xx

Reply

Mila @ Simple Harmonic Motion February 6, 2013 at 9:29 pm

Fun fact: If you use oil (I used sunflower, anything neutral should do) instead of butter in this recipe, you end up with the densest, yummiest pudding. Bonus: Use cacao, or replace part of the sugar with a hot cocoa mix :D

Reply

Claudia February 9, 2013 at 12:39 am

hi, I was just wondering how do you make the icing chocolate flavoured?

Reply

Michelle February 9, 2013 at 1:05 pm

Just made this frosting amazing, light and fluffy just as you said.I made cupcakes for my grandsons Christening and added blue foo dcolouring to make a Baby Blue Frosting. Very pleased with myself. Just as you said not to sweet perfect and light as a feather. Thank you

Reply

val February 13, 2013 at 7:02 pm

does it have to be unsalted butter?

Reply

Corinne February 13, 2013 at 9:36 pm

LOVE this icing <3 Like so many others I have been making this for EONS. I switched up a few things and it still turned out fantastic (I substituted SoDelicious Unsweetened coconut milk for the dairy and used equal amounts of coconut oil and butter instead of all butter, and powdered sugar instead of regular sugar.)

Reply

Sidra February 14, 2013 at 1:06 pm

Wow it looks yummy!.. I was looking for a good frosting recipe since i m planning to make a three tiered cake for my parents anniversary..any ideas would be most welcome!..just a question…will this frosting hold for long if not refrigerated immediately?

Reply

April February 16, 2013 at 8:58 pm

My frosting just looks like a yellow mess/ slop. It’s not white nor fluffy.

Reply

Loni February 18, 2013 at 6:40 pm

I’m looking to make a vibrant coloured icing for my son’s first birthday this weekend. If I add some food colouring paste to this, can you see it causing any problems?

Thanks!

Reply

admin February 18, 2013 at 7:58 pm

Hey Loni,

I think that should be fine! Whip it in the last step.

Andie

Reply

Mary February 20, 2013 at 7:40 pm

This is the only icing recipe my mother ever made in my lifetime. She liked it because it was not sickeningly sweet. The only difference was she only used 1 cup of sugar, not the 1 1/4 listed here. When money was tight, she used to make this with Crisco, then half crisco and half butter and eventually she was able to afford to make it with all butter. This was always a family favorite.

As far as shelf life, I am sure the health department would say it needs to be refrigerated because it is made with milk. However, my mother believed if the milk was boiled it was safe. We had cakes with this icing sitting on the counter for a week at a time. We all lived to tell about it. :-)

Reply

claire towlson February 22, 2013 at 4:31 pm

i have made this twice today and it seems too soft…cant understand why

Reply

claire towlson February 22, 2013 at 4:32 pm

does it work better with full fat butter

Reply

Vanessa February 26, 2013 at 5:14 pm

Does it matter what type of milk is used for this? Is 2% milk okay?

Reply

Andie February 26, 2013 at 9:00 pm

Hey Vanessa,

Yes, 1%, 2%, or whole milk are all perfectly fine. The only type I would steer clear of would be nonfat.

Andie

Reply

bianca March 2, 2013 at 9:32 pm

i was wondering can you use this with fondant. will the fondant stick to it??

Reply

Devon March 3, 2013 at 2:49 am

Hi I just want to ask if this frosting can stand in hot climate? like here in the philippines?
Everytime I make frostings it turns outto be runny, loose and melting… please help me with this..
Or can you share a recipe with me that can stand in hot climate?

Reply

Candice March 10, 2013 at 12:59 am

Let it be known that I have never made frosting before. Tonight I gave this recipe a go, and it came out looking like mashed potatoes. Delicious, vanilla flavoured mashing potatoes. I noticed a few other people had lumpy frosting as well, and assume it’s a result of poor mixing technique, (I’m also pretty sure I didn’t bring the butter to room temp, as some have recommended). Luckily, I’m stubborn as hell and figured out how to transform my lump-mess into smooth, delicious frosting. It can be done!

1. Whip your lump mess forever, whilst frowning. Worry that your neighbours can hear you using an electric beater at 11:30pm
2. Bust out a strainer, and strain your lump mess into a bowl. I pushed it through twice with a spatula. It was strangely satisfying.
3. Your frosting will still be a bit lumpy. Fear not! Whip the lump mess with an electric beater for six minutes, (if not a bit more). Marvel at the transformation.

The frosting was saved! It also stiffens up a bit in the fridge. Next time I’ll follow the instructions more carefully. I hope this helps anyone who ends up with a lump mess!

Reply

Amy March 11, 2013 at 8:17 pm

This frosting has a great texture. But absolutely ZERO taste. I substituted the granulated sugar for confectioner’s sugar (was aiming for better piping consistency) and used half shortening and half butter. Has anyone else done this and had no taste? I just didn’t want a strong butter taste. Will changing it back to granulated sugar really have THAT much impact? Thanks! :-)

Reply

aj March 15, 2013 at 5:03 pm

Amy, cup for cup, granulated sugar is sweeter than confectioner’s sugar. Also, all butter is tastier than half butter/half shortening. I also put a bit of salt in there at the beginning of beating to bring out the flavor, especially if I use unsalted butter. My problem is, I get these tiny lumps of the flour mixture here and there in the frosting.

Reply

Cindy Marlow March 17, 2013 at 3:35 pm

It turned out to be beautiful and as good as most people said. Thank you for the pictures and descriptions because my times were different from yours but I went for consistency rather than time and it was perfect!

Reply

Gina March 18, 2013 at 2:43 pm

We’ve had this recipe in our family for years and it’s always a hit. I’ve decorated so many birthday cakes using this perfect frosting.

Reply

Brittany March 19, 2013 at 4:03 pm

Hi. Do you think adding a little heavy whipping cream to it would make it fluffier?

Reply

Elizabeth Tennison March 20, 2013 at 1:50 pm

Can you double or triple this recipe with the same result? Have a wedding cake coming up and the bride is not a fan of butter slick taste on the tongue frostings!

Reply

Andie March 20, 2013 at 5:11 pm

I’ve doubled it without a problem, so I don’t see why you couldn’t triple it! Try it and let me know!

Andie

Reply

Kerri March 26, 2013 at 7:33 pm

Just curious since I have substituted milk with coffee flavored creamer before how that may work….giving a wide range of flavors?? I tried this past week but did have some separation issues – so going to try again and may play with the creamer instead of milk and see what happens:)

Reply

Stephanie March 29, 2013 at 9:43 pm

Cannot get the grittiness to go away! Ugh. It sounded like a good recipe, but the sugar never truly blends. Off to the store to try something else!

Reply

Lolo April 4, 2013 at 12:43 am

Hi, Would you be able to post or blog the brownie cake recipe you mention in this article?
Thanks!

Reply

Andie April 4, 2013 at 10:27 am

Hey Lolo,

I wish I could, but the recipe for Sour Cream Fudge Cake is going in my book so I can’t share it beforehand. I’m sorry :(

Andie

Reply

Joan April 5, 2013 at 9:52 am

My mother made this frosting for years for her Waldorf Astoria Cake, which is like Red Velvet. It is by far the best icing there is, so much better than the sugary, too sweet stuff. This is all we use for cupcakes, it also makes a great cupcake filling. Good post, glad to see others use this recipe also.

Reply

Jiff34 April 9, 2013 at 8:08 am

My mother in law has been making this for years. She uses half shortening and half butter and a little less sugar. I find the key to making sure your frosting is not grainy is to beat it longer. Beat it to death! Until it looks like it has almost doubled in size before you add the cooled mixture. Then beat it some more. Just when you think you’ve beaten it enough. Beat it some more. Fluff it up! Excellent on coconut cake!

Reply

Allison @ bakingyear April 9, 2013 at 12:55 pm

oh my…this frosting looks superb. I’m making this for my next cake :)

Reply

Karen April 10, 2013 at 10:40 pm

I made this frosting today and it turned out wonderful! In order for my grittiness to resolve, I had to continue whipping the frosting at high speed. Periodically I would check it, continue to whip until I reached that dreamy silky consistency that all sins should be made of. Ahem —- so, following another reviewers suggestion, I melted some semi-sweet choc chips and added it the frosting and blended it until combined. Beautiful! I simply piped it onto my cupcakes and voila! Whatever frosting that was left over, is now securely resting in my stomach. Thank you for the wonderful recipe!

Reply

Cassie April 11, 2013 at 12:47 pm

Hi! I just made this frosting today and the texture was great, but there was something a little strange about the flavor. My mom thinks it was too much vanilla, but I feel like the butter was giving it an off taste. Is imperial stick butter a good butter to use for frosting or should I try a different one? The taste pretty much went away when paired with chocolate cupcakes, but I’m not sure if it would with the white cake cupcakes.

Reply

Andie April 11, 2013 at 4:06 pm

Hey Cassie,

Hmm…I’ve never experienced any “off” flavor in this frosting–in fact, I find the flavor of this particular one to be really mild in comparison to most others. However, I could see how there might be a buttery quality to the taste given the amount used, especially if the butter you’re using isn’t the best quality. That said, I’ve never used Imperial brand so I don’t have any point of reference to judge it. Typically, I’ll use Land o’ Lakes or Kate’s brand. Another question: do you think that the milk you used could have been sour at all? Just checking.

If not, perhaps next time you make it (if you choose to), try cutting down the vanilla to 1 teaspoon and using a different brand of butter. Hope this helps and I’m sorry to hear that the flavor wasn’t a true hit!

Thanks for trying it!

Andie

Reply

Larson May 27, 2013 at 7:56 pm

Imperial is simply disgusting. It ruins everything, even macaroni and cheese. It’s definitely the Imperial that you are tasting. It’s not real butter.

Reply

SandyH June 6, 2014 at 4:09 pm

I agree, Imperial is the cheapest quality of butters.

Reply

Kati April 12, 2013 at 4:03 pm

Hi Andie,

I am making this for a get together tonight and I have two questions for you!
First, Do I need to make this right before I am planning to serve it or can it store for a bit?
Second, Can it be left out for a bit? Say two or three hours if needed? (I know there is milk in it)?

Reply

Andie April 12, 2013 at 4:47 pm

Hey Kati,

1. You can make it slightly ahead of time (I’d say no more than 2 to 3 hours).
2. Yes, this frosting is fine if left out for a while at a party. 2 to 3 hours shouldn’t be a problem!

Hope it’s loved by all!

Andie

Reply

LizB April 12, 2013 at 4:48 pm

I just made this and can answer your questions, so, I will! :) You can make it ahead of time, but it looks a lot better if you frost the cake/cupcakes immediately after you make the frosting. Then you can refrigerate the frosted cake/cupcakes. I know this because I made the frosting Wednesday, then put it in the fridge and took it out Thursday night to frost the cake – I had to let it sit out for a bit to loosen up, then I had to re-whip it and I have to say it looked fine, but it had looked a lot better when I first made it and I wished I’d frosted the cake right away! As to sitting out, I put the frosting on a cake, and within an hour of the cake being out of the fridge, the frosting began to melt and slide down the cake. :( The frosting is really delicious, but I’d say keep the frosted cake in the fridge until the *last possible moment*. I think if you were doing cupcakes or something where gravity was not involved, you’d be fine with this frosting. One other note, it was sweeter than I expected, probably a little too sweet for my taste but everyone LOVED it. :) I’ll definitely use it for cupcakes!

Reply

Kati April 12, 2013 at 4:50 pm

Thank you both for your help!

Everyone at my husbands work is very excited!

Reply

LizB April 12, 2013 at 4:52 pm

Reading what Andie just wrote, I am wondering if you frost the cake immediately and serve, you may get more time before it starts to slide? I think my make-ahead plan might not have worked so well with this frosting… maybe I’ll experiment with just making it and frosting it right away and see how long I get! :)

Reply

Dena April 16, 2013 at 6:01 pm

Hey! I’m excited to try this for my daughter’s birthday. Is it okay to use whole wheat flour? Please let me know what you think!! Thank you!

Reply

Andie Mitchell April 16, 2013 at 8:31 pm

Hey Dena!

Hmm… I haven’t tried it with whole wheat flour but I wouldn’t recommend it. Unfortunately, I think the texture and flavor would be negatively affected by the heaviness and natural nuttiness of the whole grain. All-purpose flour is lighter and will yield a softer, more mild finished product.

Hope this helps! Good luck!

Andie

Reply

Dena April 17, 2013 at 12:47 am

Yes, thank you! (I don’t care what kind of flour – just as it’s organic!) Thank you for the quick response!

Reply

Dena April 22, 2013 at 12:55 am

So, I did not do a trial run, I just went for it and made this for my daughter’s birthday cake. It was SOOO PERFECT!! This was my 2nd ever frosting also, I am not a baker. I was afraid that it would be grainy, so I put the (organic cane sugar) in the magic bullet and gave it a buzz. It was grainy when I mixed it with the butter, but when I added the cooled flour mixture, it was smooth and delish! I whipped it for about 3 min without checking it – it was already fluffy and just perfect. I piped it on the cake, no melting, no slipping. It held up so great. I was so nervous it wouldn’t come out (20 minutes before the party as I’m making this…not advised!) I was so pleased with it!! Thank you, thank you!! **side note: I used organic everything. When I mixed the flour mixture with the butter mixture I added about a tablespoon of beet powder for natural “pink” frosting. Success!!

Reply

Chris April 18, 2013 at 9:00 pm

I did not have good results. The frosting didn’t really whip, and I didn’t like the taste either. It sounded awesome, but a no go for me.

Reply

Paula April 21, 2013 at 9:52 am

Hi Andie! :)
Just wanted to let you know that this is a delicious recipe! I have made it for years and years, before me my mom made it for years and years, we both still make it. Before us, my grandmother and great-grandmother both made it. We all use it to frost Red Velvet Cake, my mom and I also use it between homemade oatmeal cookies as a filling. They are awesome! The recipe we have always used calls for 1/2 C Crisco and 1/2 C softened butter and 1 C sugar. If you blend the Crisco, softened butter and sugar well, the sugar does dissolve in this mixture. When the sugar has dissolved in the shortening and butter mixture, add the cooled custard mixture to it. Mix well and frost your goodies. Turns out light, fluffy and perfect every time!

Reply

Paula April 21, 2013 at 9:56 am

Forgot to say, add 1 t of vanilla to the sugar mixture when sugar is dissolved and mix well then add cooled custard mixture and beat well. Also if you will use a whisk to mix the flour, pinch of salt and milk custard,until it is done, you won’t have near as many lumps.

Reply

Marianne April 21, 2013 at 2:01 pm

I have 100 cupcakes to do this week for a very special event. I have a whipped buttercream recipe i normally use but its just not stable enough for what I’m doing….my questions are:
1. Does it pipe well? Meaning, holds its shape if piped with a 1M sized tip?
2. Any concerns with melting?
3. Can I decorate my cupcakes and leave out overnight?? Does it need refrigeration?

Many thanks

Reply

Dena April 22, 2013 at 12:46 am

Hey! I just made this frosting this weekend – it was great! I researched it a bunch, and saw that someone else piped it…and YES! It worked for me. It did not melt after basically being out all day. It held up and looked great BUT it did seem to sort of dry out. It got weird. Best to use right away then refrigerate. Just my opinion. Super yummy though. Very light.

Reply

Tina April 22, 2013 at 8:48 pm

I have a question, I made this as a trial run before my daughters birthday. The first time I made it, it was about the consistency of thick pancake mix, I tried mixing it longer to see if it would thicken up, but it didn’t. I now have it sitting in the freezer hoping it will thicken up in there. I made it a second time just to see if I maybe missed a step, but the same thing happened except it was even more runny. What can I do to fix it?

Reply

SandyH June 6, 2014 at 4:15 pm

I think the people here would need more information about what exactly you did before they could help. Was the butter room temp but not melted? did you let the milk completely cool before adding it (most common cause of runny icing). Did you use a whipping tool, or a mixing tool? Whippers add lots of air, mixers just mix though they do add a little air. Cooling the mix just rehardens the butter. You can try whipping the cooled mix after cooling. good luck!

Reply

rosie April 25, 2013 at 12:48 am

Made this frosting on easter for cupcakes. SOOO DELICIOUS!! Everyone liked the cupcakes but raved about the frosting

Reply

Claudia holmes April 27, 2013 at 11:21 am

I am wondering if this frosting works well for piping stars and such on decorated cakes? and how it does with coloring?

Reply

Dena April 29, 2013 at 4:39 pm

for me, it was great with both!

Reply

alexis April 28, 2013 at 4:08 am

does it hold long even in unairconditioned area’s?

Reply

Merissa May 4, 2013 at 8:04 am

Hi there:)

I love this recipe and it taste good but my flour and milk mixture is always lumpy! I have to sift it all the time. Am I doing something wrong. What should I do to make it less lumpy with clumps of flour?

Reply

Emily May 6, 2013 at 11:37 pm

This looks really good! Just had some gross frosting today…..yet i ate it all. Bleck!

Reply

khrystal May 17, 2013 at 6:38 pm

after frosting the cake, would you recommend me storing the cake in the fridge?

Reply

Claudette May 17, 2013 at 9:37 pm

Merissa, I found that the consistency of the roux must be the same as the butter/sugar mixture. When the roux is thicker than the butter/sugar the flour forms lumps which has to be sieved. It still tastes delicious anyways.

Reply

Andie Mitchell May 18, 2013 at 1:11 am

Hi Khrystal,

Yes, you should store it in the fridge afterward.

Reply

Kaytie May 27, 2013 at 6:08 pm

I was skeptical about putting flour in my frosting but this tasted amazing! I find most buttercreams are overly sweet and rather dense so I was INCREDIBLY happy with the fluffiness of this recipe and it tasted divine. The only issue I had that I noticed some others had as well was that my icing separated a little and looked slightly off. It still tasted fine, but I was wondering if you could tell me my error?
Otherwise an amazing recipe.
:)

Reply

SandyH June 6, 2014 at 4:17 pm

There were a lot of comments about not mixing it enough makes it lumpy later.

Reply

julie May 28, 2013 at 9:53 pm

This frosting was amazing! I definitlywasafraid to use flour but it was perfectly sweet :)
Can I make this ahead of time and freeze it or refrigerate it without it changing the texture or flavor? I am planning on using it for my daughters first birthday cake and don’t want it tobe ruined if I try to get it done beforethe party and wait to ice the cake the night before.

Thank you!

Reply

Deb C-N June 6, 2013 at 12:14 pm

Having read all the comments here I tried this icing this afternoon – FABULOUS!! I was in the ‘sceptical’ camp about flour in icing but it just works. There was a moment where I had added the flour mixture and it wasn’t looking special but I continued whipping and suddenly it went shiny and smooth and was like a SMB but less greasy. Top marks!!!

Reply

Bethany June 9, 2013 at 12:59 pm

I love this recipe and I have been using it for at least a year now on my baked goods. However, I would like to use it on my wedding cake for June 29th and I just made a sample of both the frosting and the cake but when I went to pipe the frosting, chunks of the roux get stuck in the tip and ruined the design. Any help on how to make sure the roux chunks go away or are very small?

Reply

Christina Braun June 16, 2013 at 10:25 pm

I’ve been making this recipe for years! A friend shared her mother’s recipe. :) I really don’t like frosting/icing – it’s just too sweet. I am the one who scrapes the frosting off of cake and cupcakes however, not this one!!!! Super easy and super good!!

Reply

apple June 25, 2013 at 3:26 am

Can i use this for cup cake or birthday cake?

Reply

Fabio June 25, 2013 at 9:03 am

Hi there,

I have to admit, I was skeptical about this, having tried so many different frosting recipes….but I really do love this one. I felt compelled to write and thank you, as this will now forever be my go-to recipe for buttercream. It takes a little more forethought and planning….and sadly not something you can whip up in a moments notice as the milk has to cool, and the butter has to warm up…but it’s worth the effort IMHO. Thank you for this wonderful recipe!

A couple of questions:

1) Have you ever tried adding more of the milk/flour mixture to the same amount of butter to cut down the sweetness even more? Just wondering if it will hold together.

2) Can this be adapted to make chocolate frosting? Is it as simple as adding cocoa powder?

Thanks!

Reply

kristy lewis June 28, 2013 at 12:20 am

Hi, I have used this icing before and I LOVE it! I just smeared in on top of cupcakes last time but im making a monster cake for my sons birthday soon and as after a frosting that would be suitable to pipe like “fur”. Does this recipe pipe easily and also would it hold its “fur” piped shape overnight if I made it the night before? Also maybe a silly question but does it take to food colouring ok? some frostings I find separate a bit when colouring is added. thanks so much

Reply

Virginia July 2, 2013 at 3:18 pm

I made the frosting and loved it. Whenever I make a white gravy I always mix the flour/ cornstarch, whatever I am using in the water/milk first. So I decided to try this with the flour and milk. It worked great. I put the milk in a jar added a tablespoon of flour at a time and shook it like crazy until all 5 Tbls. have been added. I cooked it on low as it starts to thicken fast. Was thick like cake batter in about 3 1/2 minutes. No lumps at all. At first I did taste the flour but after a couple of days didn’t taste it at all. I don’t know if this was from not cooking the 7 minutes as it said it would take. I was practicing with this recipe and it kept great in the refrigerator for several days.

Reply

Bea Long July 11, 2013 at 10:10 pm

Hey there. I don’t make a roux but I do make my butter cream with sugar and butter but the ratios are really good. I think you have to “melt” your sugar per say to really have a great butter cream. I use the one from Thomas Keller at the French Laundry Restaurant. I like to use the professionals different recipes, if I ever use powdered sugar it is no more than 2 cups not a 16 oz box that is just WAY to much. I love your site!!
Bea

Reply

Nancy keefe July 22, 2013 at 3:55 pm

Andrea it would be nice to be able to print your recipes without the hundred of comments attached…

Reply

Andie Mitchell July 24, 2013 at 11:28 am

Hey Nancy,

Just made this recipe printable!

Reply

Diane July 24, 2013 at 11:21 pm

My East Coast Aunt who was fromThe depression times used to make this frosting. When she died the recipe was lost. Well thank you for posting it. It is soo good.

Reply

Joanne Tan July 27, 2013 at 9:28 am

Wow I just tried this recipe last night and i am so going to make this agajn and again! This just taste so so gd! :)
I am not a fan of buttercream or frosting that are way too sweet but this is just nice for me. I addwd 1.5tbsp to half of this recipe for honey lemon cupcakes and I m glad I tried this!

Reply

Andrea CAdle July 28, 2013 at 2:53 pm

I used this recipe but I substituted heavy cream for the milk to get a actual whipped cream flavor. It was fabulous!! I did get the “grainy sugar” problem, but nothing a little more mixing didn’t fix! :)

Reply

Claudette July 28, 2013 at 9:53 pm

I too have been been using half whole milk and half heavy cream together with substituting two tablespoons of cornstarch for the flour to the recipe. Talk about fluffy, this is the best.

Reply

tam July 29, 2013 at 9:21 am

Firstly thank you for sharing. This recipe was so good I had to make a comment!!
It was very fluffy, mild in sweetness and creamy. My 6 year old nephew loved it. I loved it. my 50 year old mom loves it and she is really picky with sweetness.
Easy to make make. Great tasting.
Thanks again!!

*I made a modification by adding half the sugar in with the milk than the other half with the sugar and adding some mint extract along with vanilla. I didn’t have any butter so I used margarine which didn’t ( I feel) alter the taste.

Reply

Holly August 3, 2013 at 1:53 pm

this did not work in the slightest did it all properly and followed the instructions came out as liquidy YUCK.

Reply

Mei August 3, 2013 at 11:18 pm

Hi

I tried this recipe at least 3-4 time but my flour still couldn’t dissolve properly. I always end up with clump of flour in my frosting.

What did I do wrongly?

Reply

Liz August 4, 2013 at 12:55 pm

I haven’t made this frosting yet, but wanted to find out the shelf life? I’m looking for a frosting I can make a day or so in advance. Thanks for the help!

Reply

amber August 12, 2013 at 9:37 pm

anyone know if this can be made sugar free…. like with splenda or stivea or something?

Reply

connie August 13, 2013 at 8:14 pm

I have made this icing a lot and another thing in place of the milk use juice from frozen strawberries. It’s so good

Reply

jennifer August 16, 2013 at 1:50 pm

Just finished making a triple batch. Read thru the directions several times before I started. Followed everything to the “T”. It tastes great, but is runny…like pancake mix. I have read thru all of the comments and there were a few other people that had the same problem, but their questions were never answered, so I’m going to try again and ask…Is there anything I can do to thicken/fluff up the consistency? Again, I promise I followed everything to a “T”. Please help as my daughters birthday cake and cupcakes are sitting waiting to be frosted :(. Please and thank you!!!

Reply

Chrissy August 17, 2013 at 8:35 pm

Mine was runny too and as a quick fix I put the whole bowl in the freezer for a while, which sort of thickened up the frosting.

Reply

jennifer August 17, 2013 at 8:56 pm

Thanks for responding. I actually did put it in the freezer, but still could not work with it. I ended up throwing it out all together and ran to the grocery store again. I realized it didn’t work for me to triple the recipe. I made it one batch at a time. Two batches were enough and it came out perfect! My family loved the cake and had many positive comments regarding the frosting. For future reference, I would definitely not try doubling or tripling it. Worked best for me one batch at a time.

Reply

Chrissy August 17, 2013 at 8:34 pm

I must not have let it cool completely because it was more glazey and less whipped. A good flavor but hard to appreciate such sweetness when it is a little runny. Will try again.

Reply

Law August 17, 2013 at 8:44 pm

Good post and so accurate. I frequently like to post a couple remarks each day having a link to my blog. I then keep track of my traffic. Depending on the interest in the site and the post, blog traffic does increase.

Reply

Stacey September 3, 2013 at 6:41 pm

Hmm what kind of milk was used for the best results? Thanks!

Reply

Andie Mitchell September 3, 2013 at 8:22 pm

Hi Stacey,

I recommend whole milk, but I’ve used 1% milk with good results!

Andie

Reply

Stacey September 4, 2013 at 9:26 am

Thank you!:)

Reply

Paankhuri September 8, 2013 at 10:51 pm

Tried it after months of having made a mental note of it – turned out wonderfully well. Thank you for sharing!

Reply

jen September 19, 2013 at 11:25 pm

I have enjoyed this recipe thanks for sharing. We had a big event on the weekend and I was busy putting cupcakes into the freezer to ice later on the day of the party, I played with the icing ( adding cocoa powder and Cadbury drinking choc) and got good results but didn’t have enough fresh cakes to use it on so I piped icing on frozen cupcakes quickly and then put them back in the freezer. Taken out of the freezer in time to defrost for the party and they were amazing . My niece (a cake decorator) thought the choc icing was mouse and “so good” . I have also had goog results adding a few drops of lemon, lime, or orange essence to the frosting, the orange on choc cupcakes makes nice jaffa cakes.

Reply

Kate September 22, 2013 at 4:08 pm

Can I replace the granulated sugar with honey??

Reply

Jenny September 22, 2013 at 11:38 pm

Any problem adding food coloring to this recipe?

Reply

Lauren September 28, 2013 at 3:17 am

Why shouldn’t we use powdered sugar??? I’m trying to make a batch (I halved the recipe) and I beat the butter and sugar for over 10 minutes and it’s grainy as can be!!! What is the reasoning behind granulated sugar? Can I substitute powdered sugar in the same proportions? Thanks for any help!

Reply

Lauren September 28, 2013 at 3:20 am

I should also add that I’m making this recipe in Italy and I think that the butter here has a lower water content compared to American butter. Maybe there’s not enough water to dissolve the sugar?

Reply

robert kukla October 3, 2013 at 2:52 pm

Does this frosting need to be refrigerated if I use it on cupcakes? And is it stable enough that it won’t completely melt off of the cupcake at room temp. Also does it lend itself to be used as a base for different flavored buttercreams?

Reply

Mary October 7, 2013 at 2:44 pm

I just made this frosting, and it is delicious — perfectly smooth, fluffy and not too sweet. Have you ever added chocolate? I’m thinking of adding melted chocolate to the flour/milk mixture, but don’t know if the chocolate would do something weird… or maybe cocoa powder?

Reply

Sally October 12, 2013 at 11:06 pm

I used this recipe to make green tea icing for macaron fillings and all I did was mix in 2 tbsp of matcha powder. Not sure how pure chocolate would work, but I’m assuming cocoa powder will do the same. Just add in 2 tbsp and taste.

Reply

Jennifer October 8, 2013 at 12:09 pm

Getting ready to try this recipe this weekend on my son’s birthday cake. He cannot have regular sugar though. I usually substitute honey, pure maple syrup or Stevia in recipes that require sugar. Any thoughts on what would work best? Thanks!

Reply

anna October 13, 2013 at 12:15 pm

I made this and it was very very good. Everyone loved it! I will be making this many more times. Love it!

Reply

Linda October 24, 2013 at 2:38 pm

Hi!

Can I use this frosting with fondant over it?

Thanks!

Reply

sheri October 26, 2013 at 5:07 pm

I use organic evaporated cane juice which is granulated; however, my frosting still is gritty, even though I beat it for at least 3 minutes. Do you think it’s because of the sugar I used?

Reply

Kitty Cupcake October 26, 2013 at 11:36 pm

You just rocked my world with this…. thank you so much for this recipe xxxx

Reply

Jessica October 27, 2013 at 5:01 pm

I made this recipe a month ago for a cake and fell in love. Today while grocery shopping I saw Pumpkin Eggnog and made this recipe again today except I substituted the milk with the Pumpkin Eggnog….absolutely divine!! I put it on vanilla cupcakes.

Reply

Wendy October 28, 2013 at 5:10 pm

Can’t wait to try for my husband’s birthday

Reply

kelly October 30, 2013 at 7:18 pm

My frosting does not have stiff peaks how can i make it alittle stiffer?

Reply

laura October 31, 2013 at 10:37 pm

Awesome!!! loved it!!

Reply

Kristen November 5, 2013 at 3:10 pm

Hi Andie,

I absolutely love your frosting recipe! I want to make a green tea version of this to go with a matcha green tea cake. Do you have any suggestions on how I would do this? I thought about replacing the milk with green tea instead but am worried the frosting wont come out right?

-Thanks
Kristen

Reply

Chinjillavanilla February 28, 2014 at 10:53 pm

Can you add matcha powder to your roux? If the heating affected the flavor, maybe mix it in with the butter & sugar? It sounds delicious!

Reply

Soumya @ Oishi recipes November 8, 2013 at 12:07 pm

Wow I was searching for this recipe.. Just stumbled upon your site and become a subscriber. Thanks for sharing all these recipes.

Reply

Adelle November 14, 2013 at 4:20 am

Hi Andie,
Can this frosting be used for stacking cakes – Example a two tear cake with each tear filled once, or is the frosting to soft for stacking and covering with fondant?

Reply

Andie Mitchell November 14, 2013 at 8:22 am

Hi Adelle!

Yes, you can use it to frost a layer cake; it’s not too soft. The first time I made it that’s what I did and the results were great!

Andie

Reply

Susie (The Esthetic Goddess) November 20, 2013 at 1:57 pm

This is a simple yet yummy recipe. I eliminate the flour and use it as a filling for cupcakes too!

Reply

amanda November 27, 2013 at 9:30 pm

loved loved loved this recipe!! the butter cream is light and fluffy and not gritty at all. so good. and not too much sugar either! amazing. i actually added 1/2 cup of drained cut up strawberries to top a homemade cake with and it was de-li-cious!! highly recommend!! im going to use this recipe for all my cakes now :)

Reply

Kirsty December 5, 2013 at 4:50 pm

Made this for the first time last night delicious but it was a bit too soft for piping perfect for spreading. Any ideas on where I went wrong

Reply

Emma December 6, 2013 at 8:25 pm

Sounds great! Making it tomorrow. How much cocoa do I add to this recipe to make it delicately chocolatey? Thanks in advance.

Reply

Mr. Baker December 28, 2013 at 6:08 pm

One person commented that she would like to see the amount of butter reduced. I tried this a number of times with half the butter, one stick or a half cup. The frosting still tasted delicious. But no matter how long I beat the butter and sugar, and then the whole thing, the frosting remained somewhat runny and never got stiff. It was OK, but it would run slightly over the edges of the piece of cake when cut, even after days of sitting. Then I tried this with three quarters of the amount of butter, one and half sticks or three quarters of a cup. It worked fine. The frosting got to the proper consistency. Could not tell the difference between it and the full butter recipe. I now do it this way all the time.

Reply

Mr. Baker December 28, 2013 at 8:01 pm

P.S. I forgot to say that, since I reduced the amount of butter, I also went with a straight one cup of sugar rather than one and a quarter cups. It would probably work with 1 1/4 cups, but I have not tried it.

Reply

Aimee December 29, 2013 at 9:54 pm

This is, hands down, the BEST frosting I have ever had. I followed all the ingredients exactly, the only thing I did differently was blend my sugar in my ninja, which made it a little finer. It did not come out grainy, and tastes amazing on my orange cream poke cake. Thanks!

Reply

Ashley January 4, 2014 at 12:44 pm

I had to whip the frosting a little longer to get it to be quite as fluffy as yours, but it DEFINITELY turned out–I’ve never had success with homemade frosting before, so I’m SUPER excited!

Reply

Wendi January 5, 2014 at 9:53 am

Hello, I searched for whipped frosting and came across your recipe. I wanted a light frosting that would hold its shape in room temp for most of a day – this was the one! It worked great (never lost shape even though it was out for an entire afternoon), and while I couldn’t taste it myself due to dietary restrictions, everyone said it was super delicious. I also turned half of it in to chocolate by adding melted unsweetened baker’s chocolate after I’d used the first half – worked like a charm! :)

GREAT Recipe, I’ve bookmarked it for future use!

Reply

Kim January 6, 2014 at 3:49 pm

I’m not a fan of regular buttercream. I was searching the internet to find something else and found this. I just made it and I think I am officially done with buttercream! Does it hold up for wedding cakes in the south? Can I use it for piping?

Reply

aj January 7, 2014 at 1:59 pm

This icing was the most delicious thing i have ever tasted, i put this on my plain cake and inside it too and it was the best it possibly could of got, the problem is, is that i made so much icing and not enough cake that i have got a tone of icing left over, but that is fine
thank you for this recipe, it was very nice!

Reply

sara January 8, 2014 at 7:41 pm

can you make this a day before you want to use the whipped cream

Reply

Andie Mitchell January 11, 2014 at 10:06 am

Hi Sara,

It’s a good question! Unfortunately, I’ve never made it the day before I intend to use it. I’m sorry! Maybe someone else here has some insight? Anyone?

Andie

Reply

Leanne February 16, 2014 at 12:36 am

In response to Sara’s question: I made it the day before I used it, and it was still perfect.

Reply

Albert Andrus February 16, 2014 at 10:41 am

There certainly is none better and after a short time any initial grittiness from the granulated sugar disappears.

Reply

Eram January 14, 2014 at 10:41 am

Hi…does this frosting take on colors? Like bright yellow and blue?

Reply

sonia January 15, 2014 at 1:54 pm

need to make this today, how do i make this cream cheese frosting should i just add to it or substitute some of the butter for cream cheese?

Reply

Nicky January 27, 2014 at 12:00 am

Holy freakin crapola!!!!! Best whipped frosting ever!!!!! I had 75 cupcakes to frost and freaked out because I didn’t have enough confectioners sugar, I saw this recipe and decided to give it a go, and it is delicious. I used skim milk and doubled the batch with a little less sugar and it was still a little sweet but super awesome! Thanks for this recipe :)

Reply

Kristen January 31, 2014 at 5:37 pm

I made some changes but loved the way it turned out. I am a buttercream lover! The sweeter the better! YUMMY! But a majority of my family isn’t so I gave this recipe a go. I was trying to make a marshmallow buttercream that was fluffy so this is what I did… I took the 2 sticks of butter (unsalted) and creamed it with 7oz of marshmallow fluff and 3/4 cup of powdered sugar. (I didn’t want to have the gritty texture that others were talking about) I mixed that with my whisk attachment until fluffy. Then I did the milk flour vanilla mixture and let it completely cool added it and turned that on high for about 2-3 min. So fluffy and not crazy sweet. I still like it but would have added more powdered sugar if it was just for me! Piped beautifully on my strawberry cupcakes. WINNER WINNER!

Reply

Albert Andrus February 1, 2014 at 7:02 pm

Wonderful recipe! Nothing I have ever done for the first time came out right,….EXCEPT THIS! The KEY step I believe is beating the butter/sugar long enough, making certain it not only gets fluffy, but whitens as well.

Reply

Sherry February 12, 2014 at 9:31 pm

Have you ever covered a cake with this icing and fondant?

Reply

Leanne February 16, 2014 at 12:33 am

This frosting is absolutely delicious! I Iced my son’s fudge chocolate birthday cake with this heavenly stuff and received SO many compliments. I’m not into frosting, as it’s always sickly sweet, but after tasting this, I feel like I could eat it by the spoonful. Amazing! I actually didn’t use a whisk beater, but made sure to beat it for quite a few minutes longer with the regular beaters on my stand mixer. I aced it on the first try, too! I’ll never use another frosting recipe again. Thank you!

Reply

Ariella February 28, 2014 at 8:45 am

This frosting was DELICIOUS, but I did make some changes – since I was nervous about it whipping properly (I’ve had issues in the past with frostings) I added the flour, milk and sugar together and cooked them down until it formed a very thick syrup. I whipped the butter while that was cooling and then added the milk/flour/sugar mixture to the butter, and whipped that all together. It came out scrumptious – light, fluffy, but very rich. I used it to frost a Hershey’s chocolate layer cake.

Reply

Chinjillavanilla February 28, 2014 at 10:47 pm

Just made a triple batch of this to frost cupcakes and a smash cake! It is a beautiful frothy whipped sight to behold! It was sweet enough for me; I don’t think I’d want it sweeter. It is still a bit gritty with sugar, and my butter was plenty soft, but I am following the recommendations of others and chilling it overnight. It’s still so delicious I really enjoyed cleaning up… and i am not really a frosting person. This is in my top 3 icings ever. Total keeper. Thanks for a wonderful tutorial. The pics were so helpful, especially for the roux.

Reply

Albert Andrus March 1, 2014 at 9:28 am

In a few hours the graininess disappears.

Reply

Amy March 6, 2014 at 12:15 pm

Can i just add the sugar to the heated mixture to eliminate the chance of having grainy frosting? I keep seeing random comments about it? Has anyone tried putting all the sugar with the milk and just beat the butter by itself? I plan on trying this out this weekend, my sons first birthday party is the following weekend and i always like a test run!

Reply

Albert Andrus March 6, 2014 at 2:24 pm

I have heard people doing this but if you follow the recipe directions, any remaining graininess completely disappears in a few hours. The flour/milk mixture dissolves the sugar.

Reply

Jessica March 12, 2014 at 6:16 pm

How long does the frosting last in the refrigerator?

Reply

Lisa March 13, 2014 at 2:35 pm

I made this frosting and it turned out really fluffy but it has a dingy color and it had a flour taste that I did not like.

Reply

Nathan&AnthonysMomma March 17, 2014 at 4:34 am

So, I made so many substitutions that I wasn’t very hopeful for this frosting. I used a gluten free flour mix (consisted of rice flour, potato starch, and corn starch and Xanthan gum), I used margarine instead of butter and of course had to use a gluten free vanilla. I cooked the granulated sugar into the milk and gf flour mix. It was definitely not a cake mix texture, it was a thick gelatinous texture, slightly translucent around the edges. I let it cool, not very hopeful, added the butter and whipped it with my handheld mixer on its highest speed. End result is absolutely airy and wonderful I actually didn’t seen sweet enough!!! which is never my complaint about frosting. Its for St Patrick Day cupcakes for my food allergic little ones. They’ve licked the spoons and mixer blades and bowls….. I am one happy Momma. The cupcakes came of soft and moist too, worthy of this wonderful frosting! TY!!

Reply

Carol March 25, 2014 at 2:27 pm

This is by far the best icing I have tried!! Thank you for sharing.

Reply

Andrea March 27, 2014 at 4:38 pm

This is the lightest frosting that I have ever made! To make sure the sugar dissolved well with the butter, I softened the sticks of butter in the microwave and beat it for a good 3-4 minutes. I baked a cake with lemon filling so I used lemon extract instead of vanilla. It was the perfect topping! I have also made it with vanilla extract when I make a chocolate cake. I’ve never liked heavy frosting and I’ll usually scrape it off so this is the best frosting for people who like it on the lighter side. Thank you for this awesome frosting recipe!!

Reply

Penny March 28, 2014 at 7:04 pm

Can you color this frosting and does it hold up well to sit out for a party?

Reply

Rupa April 6, 2014 at 8:06 pm

Shld I use powered sugar or granulated sugar dear!
Pls tell me!
I need to try this!

Reply

Albert Andrus April 6, 2014 at 8:15 pm

Hi Rupa,

I use granulated sugar just like the recipe says. Make sure to beat it really good. Some coarseness will remain but it will soon melt into the frosting and become perfectly smooth.

Reply

Lorena Zepeda April 8, 2014 at 11:13 pm

Can this be used under fondant?

Reply

Shannon April 18, 2014 at 12:00 pm

Can I substitute Splenda for sugar? Please get back to me!

Reply

Tasha April 21, 2014 at 5:21 am

Can I use any kind of flour with this? I’m thinking coconut flour…

Reply

Albert Andrus April 21, 2014 at 8:22 am

I get excellent results with all purpose flour put thru a sifter,

Reply

Tasha April 21, 2014 at 12:32 pm

Yeah, coconut flour is pretty different than wheat flours.

Reply

Albert Andrus April 21, 2014 at 12:41 pm

Not saying it WOULDN’T work, I just have no experience with coconut flour. In fact I didn’t even know it existed. This recipe when followed properly is excellent. Myself, I use a half butter and half Crisco with superb results.

Reply

Kari May 17, 2014 at 3:43 pm

I just made this frosting and its amazing!! I did have to mix it for a really long time to get the sugar to mix properly. I even ran the sugar through the food processor before mixing with the butter. Maybe next time I’ll try running the sugar in the food processor longer. I am very excited to see how everyone likes the frosting tomorrow! How long will this store in the refrigerator?

Reply

Albert Andrus May 17, 2014 at 6:48 pm

Kari—–excessive beating is not necessary. Any graininess of the sugar melts into the frosting and completely disappears.

Reply

Janaya May 29, 2014 at 8:23 pm

I have found mixing the sugar in with the milk so that it dissolves helps a lot. I also use a little less sugar, about 1 cup, but that’s just my preference. My son doesn’t like anything uber sweet.

Reply

Andrea May 22, 2014 at 11:52 am

Does this frosting have to be refrigerated after decorating the cake? I am making a cake for a 1 year olds birthday party and it’s an outdoor cookout. It’s pretty hot here too.

Reply

Albert Andrus May 22, 2014 at 1:01 pm

Andrea——From my experience it holds up pretty well in warmer temps. You can use something like I Can’t Believe It’s Not Butter sticks with great results. It will be somewhat creamier and softer than regular butter.

Reply

pym June 3, 2014 at 2:38 pm

the 100 cal cupcake sounds great i will try it..but then the frosting with 1 cup of butter and 1 cup of sugar spoils it. no 100 cal frostings?

Reply

Kim June 3, 2014 at 4:30 pm

The frosting is super yummy! This is a million times better than my mother-in-laws’ ‘hand me down’ chalky, stiff, over powering sweet frosting. Why I like this frosting it’s not too sweet and the texture is soft and easy to ice a cake. Thanks a bunch for this recipe!

Reply

Amy M June 9, 2014 at 4:29 pm

Hey. When I made this frosting, it was delicious but it looked beady and the butter seemed to kinda separate. Did I do something wrong? Again, it tasted great and not gritty but not too attractive.

Reply

Claudia Holmes June 10, 2014 at 10:58 pm

Hi I have been making this icing for over a yr. I decorate alot of cakes and cupcakes and this is the absolute best I have used.. EVERYONE LOVES IT SO MUCH, some have even paid me extra.. :) I have alot of batches of this to do for an upcoming event and I made the flour/miilk mixture and put it in containers in the frig. Has anyone done this before and if so how did you come out with it..

Reply

Nicety Ness June 11, 2014 at 1:05 pm

Firstly I have been using this recipe over a year. I’ve never used butter only shortening. When in a hurry after cooking the milk an flour I place it in a bowl put cling over it(touching the surface so not to form a crust) an place in the freezer. Just check so it doesn’t freeze up.

Reply

Kim June 11, 2014 at 4:48 pm

After storing this in the fridge for a day and taking it out to get to room temp, it looked curdled or separated. I did save it by whipping it and adding powered sugar but it took forever and alot of sugar. Anyone else had this happen? Should I have just left it sit at room temp and not put in the fridge? Does it hold up at room temp on a cake?

Reply

Albert Andrus June 11, 2014 at 9:49 pm

Kim——- This frosting will hold up well at room temp. I use granulated sugar, not powdered. Any remaining graininess after the initial beating will disappear because sugar melts into the frosting.

Reply

Megan June 17, 2014 at 7:12 pm

I just made this, followed the recipe exactly and it turned out horrible. Very grainy.

Reply

Albert Andrus June 17, 2014 at 10:16 pm

Megan——-At first it will be a bit grainy but shortly the sugar granules melt into the frosting making it very creamy.

Reply

Dani July 2, 2014 at 9:29 pm

is there a gluten free version to this ?
ive been looking for something to fill a gluten free cake thats not too sweet.
if you can, answer this soon!

Reply

Mr. Baker July 2, 2014 at 9:37 pm

Dani, Just substitute cornstarch for the flour. Then you will have a gluten-free frosting. I have found that it takes less cornstarch than flour. Rather than five tablespoons of flour, I have used four tablespoons of cornstarch, and it is still thicker than with the flour. Perhaps three tablespoons of cornstarch would be enough. When made with cornstarch (four tablespoons), I find it harder to fully blend the cornstarch/milk mixture with the butter/sugar mixture.

Reply

Dani July 2, 2014 at 9:38 pm

Do you think it’d work with gluten free baking flour?

Reply

Mr. Baker July 2, 2014 at 9:44 pm

It should work fine with gluten-free baking flour. You will know for sure when you see the milk thicken. I do prefer the texture when made with flour rather than with cornstarch.

Reply

Dani July 2, 2014 at 10:44 pm

the end result tastes and looks strange. almost as if the butter separated itself from the whole thing. looks like small oily dots everywhere. it also tastes too buttery. do you know why this happened and what i can do to fix it? any suggestions would be greatly appreciated!

Reply

Mr. Baker July 2, 2014 at 11:06 pm

I have never seen what you describe, so can only guess as to the cause. If there are small oily dots of separated butter, possibly the thickened milk had not completely cooled before you blended it with the whipped butter/sugar mixture, and the warmth partially melted the butter. The other possible cause would be that the butter/sugar mixture was not beaten long enough to be fully whipped. It should get fairly stiff, and this takes a while. If it was fully whipped, the only thing that would cause separation is that the thickened milk was not all the way cool when blended with it. As for a possible fix (and I stress “possible”), make sure that it is entirely cool, and keep beating it for a while to try to get it re-blended (or re-whipped).

Reply

Dani July 2, 2014 at 9:49 pm

okay thanks! so gluten free flour instead of cornstarch.
i was worried about it because i made a gluten free cake with it and it had a powdery feel to it.

Reply

Adel July 8, 2014 at 3:37 pm

I did a practice run of this last week in preparation for making my son’s birthday cake this week. It totally flopped, and after reading all the comments, I don’t know what I did wrong! I was religious about chilling everything, and it actually was ok, smooth and just a little gritty and fluffy, although it would be a major stretch to call it “light as whipped cream”. I refrigerated it and then pulled it out the next day to frost a cake. I r-whipped it and it totally went flat with little buttery lumps! It wasn’t gritty anymore, I’ll say that much. Now I’m trying to decide whether to try another recipe or see if I can do better in this one, but either way I’m afraid of messing up another one. :(

Reply

Jenn July 16, 2014 at 7:08 pm

Is there anywhere I can use this recipe and make it a chocolate 7 minute frosting? If anyone has tried, please pass along!! Thanks!

Reply

Alyssa Ruiz July 18, 2014 at 8:52 pm

Hi, is there a trick to softening the butter? My flavor fluffiness came out great but the butter is still in very tiny clumps no matter how long I mix.

Reply

Albert Andrus July 19, 2014 at 9:19 am

10 seconds in a microwave does the trick.

Reply

Marcus July 31, 2014 at 7:15 pm

Yesterday, I made a vanilla-bean cupcake filled with a fresh strawberry filling. I was trying to get a similar vibe of a strawberry shortcake, in cupcake form of course. At first, I was going to make a thick whipped cream to pipe onto the cupcakes, but unless kept in a refrigerator, it would lose its freshness and consistency. Then, I thought about doing a traditional vanilla buttercream instead. However – I realized it would be too sweet for my taste and overpower the flavor of the cake and filling. I did some research and found this recipe for cooked frosting. Reading the positive comments, I went ahead and decided that this was the perfect topping for my dessert. The recipe itself is truly fantastic and will be my go-to option for any cake recipe. After reading some of the comments, I did a few things to avoid some of the problems others encountered. Since some commented that the frosting had a grainy texture due to an incomplete incorporation of the sugar, I simply improvised. I added the sugar to the flour/milk mixture, instead of creaming it with the butter. It fully dissolved during the stovetop procedure, so the frosting had a 100% smooth texture and no graininess. Secondly, I cooked all of the ingredients as the recipe said – but after the seven minutes of cooking, I passed the mixture through a fine mesh sieve to remove future lumps from my frosting. It was not too thick at that point, so it was not too difficult. Finally, I let it cool completely, stirring the flour/milk/sugar/vanilla mixture every few minutes. Then, I followed the rest of the recipe and it turned out to be an amazing treat. I usually think frosting is too sweet and don’t eat it, but I could definitely eat a bowl of just this. Be sure to try it out and do what I did if you have any problems :)

Reply

lunablue August 3, 2014 at 8:07 pm

Easier and quicker than I expected. Ran out of vanilla extract after 1 1/2Tbs so added a little almond extract. Wasn’t grainy after the flour mixture was incorporated. Tastes like a rich buttery whipped cream that actually has flavor. Can’t wait to try it on the finished cake. Used salted sweet cream butter since that’s what I had on hand. Thank you for the recipe.

Reply

Shari August 28, 2014 at 1:37 pm

Does anyone have the calories per serving and nutritional breakdown for this icing? I found it for the cupcake recipe, but don’t see it here. Thanks!

Reply

Leave a Comment

{ 35 trackbacks }

Previous post:

Next post: